Full Length Research Paper
J. S. Price1* and R. Gardner, Jr2
1Consultant Psychiatrist, Sussex NHS Partnership Trust, Brighton General Hospital, Elm Grove, Brighton BN2 3EW, UK.
2Clinical Professor of Psychiatry, University of Wisconsin Medical School Madison WI, USA.
Two ancient texts feature a hero who does not submit completely to his deity. One, Arjuna, depicted in the Bhagavad Gita, decided not to fight in defiance of his mentor and deity Krishna. The other, Job of the Old Testament, complained bitterly that his god treated him unfairly. Both suffer affective disturbance. Arjuna, dejected, displays a panic attack, Job shows severe depression. After each interacts with his god and actually sees the divine form, each submits totally and then experiences symptom relief. These old texts support the claim of some contemporary religious congregations that submission to their respective gods relieves depression and anxiety to bring peace and joy. We pursue two implications: (1) Might psychotherapy learn from this and explore secular equivalents of submission to supernatural being(s)? (2) By what mechanism does submission to a god relieve depression? We call on longstanding evolutionary theories to which we have contributed about the relation of submission to depression. From this we tentatively conclude that whereas belief in a god may alleviate existential anxiety about the meaning of life and what happens after death, submission to such a supernatural figure is required for the relief of depressed mood.
Key words: Arjuna, Book of Job, Bhagavad Gita, depression, dejection, triune brain, submission, incomplete submission, deities.
|Á Kempis T (1952). The Imitation of Christ. Translated by Leo Sherley-Price. New York; Penguin Classics.|
Barkow J.H. (1991) Précis of Darwin, Sex and Status: biological approaches to mind and culture. Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 14, 295-334.
|Bowlby J (1980). Attachment and Loss. Loss Sadness and Depression. London: Hogarth Press Vol 3.|
|Chance MRA. (1996). A socio-mental bimodality: A pre-hominid inheritance. In Steele, J. and & Shennan, S. (Eds.), The Archaeology of Human Ancestry, London: Routledge. pp. 103-147.|
|De Waal F (1985). Chimpanzee Politics. London: Jonathan Cape.|
|De Waal F (1988). The reconciled hierarchy. In Social Fabrics of the Mind (ed. M.R.A.Chance) Hove: Lawrence Erlbaum. pp. 297-312.|
|Dowd M (2007).Thank God for Evolution. New York: Viking.|
|Ellis TB (2009). Natural gazes, non-natural agents: the biology of religion's ocular behaviors. In The Biology of Religious Behavior: The Evolutionary Origins of Faith and Religion. Edited by Feierman JR. New York: Praeger.|
Feierman JR. (2009a). How Religion Could Have Evolved. In: The Biological Evolution of Religious Mind and Behavior. Edited by Voland E, Schiefenhovel W. New York: Springer-Verlag.
|Feierman JR. (2009b). The Evolutionary History of Religious Behavior. In The Biology of Religious Behavior: The Evolutionary Origins of Faith and Religion. Edited by Feierman JR. New York: Praeger.|
|Fernald RD (2002). Social regulation of the brain: sex, size and status. Novartis Foundation Symposium; 244:169-84; Discussion 184-186, 203-206, 253-257.|
Flannelly KJ, Koenig HG, Galek K (2007) Beliefs, mental health, and evolutionary threat assessment systems in the brain. J. Nerv. Ment. Dis. 195: 996-1003.
|Fry DP (2007). Beyond war: The Human Potential for Peace.|
|Galanter M (1989). Cults and New Religious Movements. Washington, DC, Am. Psychiatr. Assoc.|
|Gardner R, Wilson DR (2003). Sociophysiology and the Evolutionary Aspects of Psychiatry. Chapter 20, in Biological Psychiatry. Editor: Jaak Panksepp, Wiley and sons.|
Gilbert P (2006). Evolution and depression: issues and implications. Psychol Med; 36: 287-297.
|Glass JD (2007). The Power of Faith: Mother Nature's Gift. Corona del Mar, CA: Donnington Press.|
Greenberg N, Crews D (1983). Physiological ethology of aggression in amphibians and reptiles. In Hormones and Aggressive Behavior. B.B.Svare (Ed.). New York, Plenum Press, pp.469-506.
|Grou, J (1892). Manual for Interior Souls. London, Burns Oates & Washburn.|
|Hartley JE (1988). The Book of Job. Grand Rapids, MI: Erdmann.|
|Kahn J (1986). Job's Illness: Loss, Grief and Integration; A Psychological Interpretation. London, Gaskell.|
Kapusta MA, Solomon F (1977). The book of Job and the modern view of depression. Annals of Internal Medicine. 86: 667-672.
Koenig HG (2008). Religion and mental health: what should psychiatrists do? Psychiatr. Bull. 32: 201-203.
Koenig HG, McCulloch ME, Larson DB (1998). Handbook of Religion and Health. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
|Kortmulder K, Robbers Y (2005). The Agonic and Hedonic Styles of Social Behaviour. Lewiston: The Edwin Mellen Press.|
|Lewis CS (1940). The Problem of Pain. New York, Collier Books; 1940.|
McMinn MR, Ruiz JN, Marx D (2006). Professional psychology and the doctrines of sin and grace: Christian leaders' perspectives. Professional Psychology: Res Pract. 37(3): 295-302.
|MacLean PD (1990). The Triune Brain in Evolution. New York, Plenum Press.|
|McNamara P, Trumbull D (2007). An Evolutionary Psychology of Leader-Follower Relations. New York: Nova Science Publishers.|
McConnell KM, Pargament KI, Ellison CG (2006). Examining the links between spiritual struggles and symptoms of psychopathology in a national sample. J. Clin. Psychol. 62(12): 1469-1484.
|Mitchell S (1994). The Book of Job. London, Kyle Cathie.|
|Mitchell S (2002) The Bhagavad Gita: A New Translation. New York, Three Rivers Press.|
Mushtaq I, Hafeez MA (2008). Psychiatrists and role of religion in mental health. Psychiatr Bull. 32: 395.
|Narayan RK (1978). The Mahabharata: A Shortened Modern Prose Version of the Indian Epic. London: Penguin.|
|Nesse RM (2006). Evolutionary explanations for mood and mood disorders. In Textbook of Mood Disorders. Edited by Stein DJ, Kupfer DJ, Shatzberg AF. Washington DC: American Psychiatric Publishing Inc., pp. 159-178.|
Nesse RM (2000). Is depression an adaptation? Archives of General Psychiatry, 57: 14-20. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Pies R (2008). The anatomy of sorrow: a spiritual, phenomenological, and neurological perspective. Phil. Ethics Human. Med, 3: 17.
|Postanowicz R (2008). "African Wild Dogs". http://www.lioncrusher.com/animal.asp?animal=2.|
Price JS (1991). Homeostasis or change? A systems theory approach to depression. Brit. J. Med. Psychol., 64: 331-344.
Price JS (1992). The agonic and hedonic modes: definition, usage, and the promotion of mental health. World Futures 35: 87-115.
Price JS, Gardner R, Erickson M (2004). Can depression, anxiety and somatisation be seen as appeasement displays? Journal of Affective Disorders. 79: 1-11.
|Price JS, Gardner R, Wilson DR (2007). Territory, rank and mental health: the history of an idea. Evol. Psychol. 5(3):531-554.|
Price JS, Sloman L, Gardner Jr. R, Gilbert P, Rhode P (1994). The social competition hypothesis of depression. Briti. J. Psychiatr. 164: 309-315.
|Rolston H (2002). Genes, Genesis and God: Values and Their Origins in Natural and Human history. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.|
Rosen IC (2007). Revenge – the hate that dare not speak its name: a psychoanalytic perspective. J. Am. Psychoanal Assoc. 55: 595-620.
|Schumaker JF (1992). Introduction. In Religion and Mental Health. Edited by Schumaker JF. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 3-32.|
|Slater E, Roth M (1969). Clinical Psychiatry. (Third edition). London: Bailliere, Tindall & Cassell, p. 209.|
|Stein DJ (2006). Evolutionary psychiatry: Integrating evolutionary theory and modern psychiatry. Prog. Neuro-Psychopharm. Biol. Psychiatr. 30 (5): 765.|
|Stevens A, Price J (2000a). Evolutionary Psychiatry: A New Beginning. Second edition. London, Routledge.|
|Stevens A, Price J (2000b). Prophets, Cults and Madness. London, Duckworth, 2000.|
Trice PD, Bjork JP (2006). Pentecostal perspectives on causes and cures of depression., Professional Psychology: Res Pract. 37(3): 283-294.
|Wampold B (2001). The Great Psychotherapy Debate: Models, Methods, and Findings. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Publishers.|
|Wilson DR (in press) In defence of evolutionary psychiatry: a counter-parry to past ripostes. In: A. De Block and P.R.Adriaens (eds.) Darwin and Psychiatry: Philosophical Perspectives. Oxford: Oxford University Press.|
|Wilson DR, Cory GA (2007). Evolutionary Epidemiology of Mania and Depression: A Theoretical and Empirical Interpretation of Mood Disorders. New York: Mellen Press.|
Yalom ID (1999). Momma and the Meaning of Life. New York: Basic Books, pp. 5-6.
|APA||(2009). Does submission to a deity relieve depression? Illustrations from the book of Job and the Bhagavad Gita. Philosophical Papers and Review, 1(2), 17-31.|
|Chicago||J. S. Price and R. Gardner, Jr. "Does submission to a deity relieve depression? Illustrations from the book of Job and the Bhagavad Gita." Philosophical Papers and Review 1, no. 2 (2009): 17-31.|
|MLA||J. S. Price and R. Gardner, Jr. "Does submission to a deity relieve depression? Illustrations from the book of Job and the Bhagavad Gita." Philosophical Papers and Review 1.2 (2009): 17-31.|