African Journal of
Agricultural Research

  • Abbreviation: Afr. J. Agric. Res.
  • Language: English
  • ISSN: 1991-637X
  • DOI: 10.5897/AJAR
  • Start Year: 2006
  • Published Articles: 6801

Full Length Research Paper

Assessment of soil characteristics under four cropping and land management systems in south west Nigeria

Wasiu Agunbiade Lamidi
  • Wasiu Agunbiade Lamidi
  • Department of Agronomy, College of Agriculture, Ejigbo Campus, Osun State University, Osogbo, Nigeria.
  • Google Scholar
Onyegbula Chike Nwoke
  • Onyegbula Chike Nwoke
  • Department of Agronomy, College of Agriculture, Ejigbo Campus, Osun State University, Osogbo, Nigeria.
  • Google Scholar
Kabiru Alani Shittu
  • Kabiru Alani Shittu
  • Department of Agronomy, College of Agriculture, Ejigbo Campus, Osun State University, Osogbo, Nigeria.
  • Google Scholar

  •  Received: 13 February 2017
  •  Accepted: 12 February 2018
  •  Published: 05 July 2018


Soil degradation and desertification pose a major threat to agricultural production in sub-Saharan Africa. The influence of cropping systems which had been established on selected physical and chemical properties of soil were investigated in Akinyode-Okinni community in Egbedore Local Government Area (LGA) of Osun State, Nigeria. The cropping systems included agri-silviculture (SCM), silvi-pasture (SPC), agri-horti-silviculture (PAH) and agroforestry (AFT) selected from existing farms in the community. The selected plots had cocoa (Theobroma cacao), oil palm (Elais guineensis) and kola-nut (Kola nitida) as permanent crops; coco-yam (Coco nucifera), guinea grass (Panicum maximum), plantain (Musa spp), maize (Zea mays), and cassava (Manihot utilissima) were the annual crops. The experiment was carried out for two cropping seasons. Results showed that in the AFT system bulk density (BD) decreased slightly from 1.22 to 1.16 g/cm3 in the top soil and from 1.18 to 1.09 g/cm3 in the subsoil after two seasons of crop growth. The pH varied between 6.40 and 7.05 in the first season and between 7.05 and 7.29 after two seasons. On average, the topsoil contained more organic carbon (OC) in the SPC (38 g kg-1) and SCM (36 g kg-1) systems than in the PAH and AFT systems. Similarly, the total phosphorus content was higher in the topsoil of SPC and SCM systems than in the other systems. There was a slight reduction in soil acidity and no significant changes occurred in the concentrations of exchangeable bases after two cropping seasons. Conclusively, these cropping systems have the potential to reduce soil deterioration and thus, further studies to develop appropriate management strategies are necessary.

Key words: Cropping systems, exchangeable bases, organic carbon, silviculture, soil degradation.



The influence of soil management practices on sustainable agricultural production could be related to the readiness of farmers to adopt improved agricultural practices. One of the goals of effective soil management practices is to create farming systems that mitigate environmental degradation associated with  inappropriate activities of man (Sustainable Agriculture, 2001). Sustainable agriculture is part of a larger movement toward sustainable developmental processes, which recognize natural resources as being finite; it acknowledges limits on economic growth, and encourages equity in distribution of resources (Horrigan et al., 2002). The adoption of certain agricultural technologies which are believed to be yield-enhancing and development oriented can bring ecological, socio-economic, and cultural benefits if based on a holistic scientific approach (Madden and Chaplowe, 1997). Potential sustainable agricultural practices that may have impact on some developmental processes on soil management include organic farming, crop rotation, planting of cover crops, conservation tillage, integrated soil fertility cum nutrient management, enhancement and conservation of bio-diversity, integrated pest management, rotational grazing, and agro-forestry (Factsheet of Tropical Forages, 2015; Lamidi, 2013; Michel, 2010; Alabadan et al., 2009; Sustainable Agriculture, 2001; Allan, 1996).

This study focused on four soil management systems which are considered important in the quest to develop sustainable agricultural production systems. These systems include agri-silviculture, agri-silvipasture, agri-horti-silviculture, and agroforestry. In agri-silviculture farmers in dryland grow field crops in combination with forest trees; the silvi-pastoral system involves raising grasses instead of field crops in the spaces between forest trees (Balasubramaniyan and Palaniappan, 2005). Agri-silvipasture is the combination of agri-silviculture and silvi-pastoral systems whereas agri-horti-silviculture is a system where fruit trees are grown along with crops and multipurpose tree species. Agri-horti-silviculture is highly diverse in vegetation and its productive capacity is expected to be relatively high. For example, crops such as rice, mustard, soybean and/ or vegetables may be grown in between banana or guava (Balasubramaniyan and Palaniappan, 2005). The general assumption is that these agricultural systems have the capacity to restore and balance ecosystems naturally (Factsheet of Tropical Forages, 2015; Ifeanyi et al., 2013).

Thus, it was hypothesized that farmers’ adoption of developmental soil management practices could have an impact on the physical and chemical properties of the soil. Therefore, this study examined the influence of four cropping and land management systems on selected physical and chemical properties of the soil after two cropping seasons in South West Nigeria.



The study was conducted at Oluyeyin Akinode-Oke Farm (5.56°N, 4.56°E) in Okinni village located at Egbedore Local Government Area of Osun State,  Nigeria.  The  soil  is  well  drained  and  sandy loam in texture. The mean annual rainfall is between 300 and 350 mm. The area is prone to soil erosion. Four agricultural systems which had been established by farmers were selected for the study. These systems were agri-silviculture, silvi-pastural, agri-horti-silviculture, and agroforestry.

Agri-silviculture is a system of agriculture where the land is used to produce both forest trees and agricultural crops either simultaneously or alternately (Balasubramaniyan and Palaniappan, 2005). Silvi-pastural system is where trees are planted for wood production as well as fodder for feeding domestic animals. Agri-horti-silviculture is a system of agriculture where annual crops, fruit trees and multipurpose tree species are planted on a piece of land simultaneously or alternately. The agroforestry system was taken as a system having tree species as a major feature or a combination of all the other systems already described. The size of each of the selected cropping systems was 1 ha which was divided into four segments to serve as replicates.

The agri-silviculture system had three-year old cocoa trees which served as forest tree crop and plantain at the commencement of the study; maize (Zea mays) was grown in between the rows for two cropping seasons and the system was tagged SCM. The silvi-pastural system also had three-year old cocoa trees with guinea grass (Panicum maximum) grown between the rows and was tagged SPC; grazing was discouraged during the period of the experiment. The agri-horti-silviculture system, tagged PAH, had oil palm (Elais guineensis) and cocoa trees; maize was grown in the rows of the tree crops. In PAH system, cocoa served as a fruit tree crop, oil palm as a multipurpose tree species, and maize as a field crop. The agro-forestry system tagged AFT, had fully grown kola-nut (Kola nitida) trees which were regarded as forest tree species. A nearby field (same neighbourhood, of similar size) with secondary regrowth of vegetation (bush fallow) was selected as the control plot.

Soil samples were taken from each plot at two depths, 0 to 15 and 15 to 30 cm, prior to commencement of the study and after two cropping seasons. Soil samples were also taken from the control field for comparison. The samples were air-dried, sieved (2 mm) and analysed for physical and chemical characteristics. The parameters measured included particle size fractions, pH, total P, organic carbon, total N and exchangeable cations (Essington, 2004; Davidson and Ackerman, 1993; IITA, 1982). Core soil samples were also taken for determination of bulk density (BD) (Hamza and Anderson, 2005; Hakansson and Lipiec, 2000). The data obtained were subjected to One-way analysis of variance (ANOVA), the treatment means of the data were separated with least significant difference (LSD).



Physical properties (bulk density (BD) and particle size fractions)

Generally the influence of the cropping systems on BD of the topsoil was not visible during the experimental period as shown in Table 1. However, when considered on absolute terms, a slight decrease was observed in some systems. For example, in the topsoil of the AFT system BD decreased from 1.22 to 1.16 g/cm3. Similarly the BD of the subsoil tended to decrease slightly in PAH (1.22 to 1.06 g cm-3) and SCM (1.21 to 1.17 g cm-3) systems.

The relatively low BD values after two seasons suggest some improvement in this soil property which apparently, would have influenced some other properties of the soil. The slight decrease in BD could be attributed to the no-till strategy adopted for cropping systems with permanent crops. The absence of trampling by grazing animals may have contributed to the slight reduction in BD since grazing was discouraged in the experimental fields during the period of the study. In essence, the agricultural development systems used for this study could be described as being environmentally friendly because of their perceived lowering effect on BD which translates to occurrence of little or no soil compaction. It is common knowledge that soil compaction causes physical impedance of roots and thus limits access to water and nutrients by reducing the volume of soil exploited by plant roots.



This attribute is particularly important since compaction destroys the structural units of the soil and, thus alters the pore spaces which invariably affect aeration and water infiltration negatively (Taylor and Brar, 1991). Moreover, when BD is high (≥ 1.5 g cm-3) root growth and development can be depressed (Hassan et al., 2007).

Data on particle size fractions of the surface and subsurface layers are given in Table 2. At the commencement of the experiment, the amount of sand particles varied from 704 to 760 g kg-1 in the top soil while the silt particles ranged from 123 to 182 g kg-1. In the subsoil, the sand fraction varied from 694 to 762 g kg-1 whereas the silt fraction varied from 113 to 192 g kg-1. The quantity of the clay fraction was, on average, 114 g after two cropping seasons were, more or less, similar to the initial values (data not shown) indicating little or no kg-1 for the topsoil and 122 g kg-1 for the subsoil. The soils in (sandy loam).  The particle size fractions measured change during the period of study. In general, there was no evidence of change in their distribution after two cropping seasons.



This observation is encouraging since the cropping systems were established by farmers to reduce erosion conserve to the soil. As the cropping systems contained plant species which shed some of their the various cropping systems had same textural class leaves regularly, the resulting  litter  may  have  reduced  surface runoff and prevented dislodgement and removal of fine soil particles. In addition, the no-till strategy adopted may have contributed in preserving the soil. 

Chemical properties (organic carbon, pH, exchangeable bases, total phosphorus, and total nitrogen)

The organic carbon content of the topsoil of the SPC or SCM system was similar to the control which had secondary vegetation that remained untouched during the experimental period but higher than that of the PAH or AFT system (Figure 1). More organic carbon was measured in the topsoil than in the subsoil in all the cropping systems except AFT whose topsoil contained the lowest amount.



The value of organic carbon is an indication of the soil organic matter (SOM) content in agricultural soils (Obigbesan, 2000). The observed organic carbon content suggests that SOM was not negatively affected by the activities conducted in these cropping systems. Both SPC and SCM systems had 3-year old cocoa trees at the beginning of the experiment which may have contributed to the replenishment or maintenance of the organic carbon content through its litter. The reason for the relatively low amount of organic carbon measured in the topsoil of the AFT system is unclear since it contained kola nut trees that would shed its leaves and contribute to SOM upon decomposition; the amount of litter in each of the cropping systems was, however, not quantified in this study.

It was observed that the pH the topsoil at the commencement of the study was either slightly acidic or nearly neutral in all the cropping systems while that of the subsoil of all the systems varied from neutral to slightly alkaline except the control field which had a near neutral pH  (Table  2).  However,  results  showed  that after   the  two cropping seasons, the pH of the subsoils of all the cropping systems had become neutral or slightly alkaline. Although it has been reported that agricultural practices such as zero tillage which contribute to SOM build up also promote soil acidity (Adepetu et al., 2014), the no-till strategy adopted in this study did not reduce the pH of the soil.  For example, in the systems (SPC and SCM) where the amount of organic carbon in the topsoil was relatively high and comparable to the control, and given that zero tillage was employed, the soil did not become acidic. This assertion is supported by the pH (measured in water) of the soil which ranged between slightly acid to neutral before cropping and ranged between neutral to slightly alkaline after cropping.

Data on exchangeable bases and acidity measured on samples taken just before the commencement of the experiment are shown in Table 3. In the topsoil, exchangeable Ca varied from 4.5 to 12 Cmol kg-1 among the cropping systems whereas the variation in quantity of exchangeable Mg was not wide. The cropping systems also had similar amounts of exchangeable K and Na in the topsoil. The amounts of these nutrients in the cropping systems did not change appreciably after two cropping seasons (Table 4). Thus, the concentrations of these nutrient elements were somewhat stable during the study period probably due to addition of organic matter to the soil through fallen leaves and dead roots. However, the concentrations of most of the measured cations generally fall within the low range (Adepetu et al., 2014) except those of the SPC (topsoil) and AFT (subsoil) cropping systems that were within the medium class. Considering the critical limits of soil nutrients reported by Aderonke and Gbadegesin (2013), the amount of exchangeable K was generally in the medium range. Nevertheless, the low levels of exchangeable cations indicate the need for adequate soil management in all the cropping systems to boost the productive capacity of the soil. Cation exchange is  important  in  soil  as  it  controls availability of nutrients to plants, prevents leaching of the nutrients, and ensures their release for plant uptake; low levels of exchangeable cations are usually attributed to leaching and soil erosion (Negassa, 2001). But in this study, soil erosion was minimal as there was no significant redistribution of particle size fractions.




The topsoil of the SPC and SCM systems contained more total P than the topsoil of the other systems as  well as the control (Figure 2). The amount of total P in the subsoil was generally lower than in the topsoil in all the cropping systems except AFT. The results indicated that total P varied between 0.068 to 0.273% (mean = 0.184%) in the topsoil and between 0.095 to 0.147% (mean = 0.118%) in the subsoil. These mean values could translate to 1.84 g kg-1 for the topsoil and 1.18 g kg-1 for the subsoil. The amounts of total P  in  the  topsoil  of  the studied cropping systems are relatively high when compared with other soils. For example, the amount of total P in the top layer of some soils in the study region has been reported to vary from 90 to 198 mg kg-1 (Nwoke et al., 2004). The relatively high total P content observed in this study might be due to organic matter input from the associated trees and could buffer P in soil solution for uptake by growing crops.



The concentration of total N in the topsoil of the cropping systems varied from 0.201 to 0.390% while 0.212 to 0.319% in the subsoil (Figure 3). The trend was similar to that of total P; similar amounts were measured in the topsoil of the SPC and SCM systems and these were higher than the amount measured in the other systems. The results indicated that soil nitrogen is relatively high in these cropping systems based on a scale for maize production reported by Aderonke and Gbadegesin (2013). The authors had classified soil nitrogen > 0.15% as high, and the total N content of the topsoil in the present study was greater than this  even  in the control treatment probably due to addition of organic matter (that is plant litter).









Data on soil nutrient concentrations and the apparent stable particle size fractions after two cropping seasons suggest that, these cropping systems have the potential to minimise erosion and reduce soil deterioration. However, the differences in the total N and P, and organic C contents among the cropping systems necessitate further studies to develop appropriate management strategies to optimise the benefits that might be derived from the cropping systems.



The authors have not declared any conflict of interests.



Adepetu JA, Adetunji MT, Ige DV (2014). Soil fertility and crop nutrition. Soil Organic Matter pp. 92-96, 109, 440.


Aderonke DO, Gbadegesin GA (2013). Spatial variability in soil properties of a continuously cultivated land. African Journal of Agricultural Research, 8(5):475-483.


Alabadan BA, Adeoyo PA, Folorunso EA (2009). Effect of different poultry wastes on physical, chemical and biological properties of soil. Caspian Journal of Environmental Sciences, 7(1):31-35.


Allan W (1996). Soils and the Environment. An Introduction. Cambridge Low Priced Edition, Cambridge University Press pp. 44-46.


Balasubramaniyan P, Palaniappan SP (2005). Principles and Practices of Agronomy, second edition, Agrobios (India) pp. 396-406.


Davidson EA, Ackerman IL (1993). Changes in soil carbon inventories following cultivation of previously untilled soils. Journal Biogeochemical, 20:161-193.


Essington ME (2004). Soil and Water Chemistry- An Integrative Approach. CRC Press, New York.


Factsheet of Tropical Forages (2015). Factsheet of Tropical Forages-Panicum Maximum-morphology, 


Hassan FU, Ahmad M, Ahmad N, Kaleen Abbasi M (2007). Effects of subsoil compaction on yield and yield attributes of wheat in the sub-humid region of Pakistan. Soil and Tillage Research, 96:361-366.


Hakansson I, Lipiec J (2000). A review of the usefulness of relative bulk density values in studies of soil structure and compaction. Soil Till. Res. 53:71-85.


Hamza MA, Anderson WK, (2005). Soil compaction in cropping systems. A review of the nature, causes and possible solutions. Soil Till. Res 82:121-145.


Horrigan L, Lawrence RS, Walker P (2002). How Sustainable Agriculture can address the Environmental and Human Health Harms of Industrial Agriculture. Centre for Livestock Future, John Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, Baltimore, Maryland, USA.


Ifeanyi-obi CC, Adesope OM, Issa FO, Ugwuja VC (2013). Organic Agriculture as Resuscitating Option for Cocoyam Production in Nigeria. International Journal of Applied Research and Technology, 2(6):196-202.


International Institute of Tropical Agriculture (IITA) (1982). Automated and semi-automated Methods for Soil and Plant Analysis. Manual series number 7. IITA, Ibadan 33p.


Lamidi WA (2013). Conventional and Organic Cropping systems of Farming in Osun State of Nigeria. Agriculture and Biology Journal of North America, (ABJNA) 4(2):103109


Madden JP, Chaplowe SG (1997). Eds, For All Generations making World Agriculture more Sustainable. Glendale, CA, World Sustainable Agriculture Association.


Michel KY, Pascal KTA, Soueymane K, Jerome ET, Yao T, Luc A, Danielle B (2010). Effects of land use types on soil organic carbon and nitrogen dynamics in mid-west Cote d'Ivoire. European Journal of Scientific Research, 2:211-222.


Negassa W (2001). Assessment of Important Physicochemical Properties of Nitosols under Different Management Systems in Bako Area, Western Ethiopia. M.Sc. Thesis, Alemaya University, Alemaya P 109.


Nwoke OC, Vanlauwe B, Diels J, Sanginga N, Osonubi O (2004). The distribution of phosphorus fractions and desorption characteristics of some soils in the moist savanna zone of West Africa. Nutrient Cycling in Agroecosystems, 69:127-141.


Obigbesan GO (2000). Plant mineral nutrition in Nigeria: My experience. Agronomy in Nigeria P 188.


Sustainable Agriculture Network (2001). Exploring Sustainability in Agriculture: Ways to Enhance Profits, protect the Environment and Improve the Quality of Life. 


Taylor HM, Brar GS (1991). Effect of soil compaction on root development. Soil and Tillage Research, 19:111-119.