African Journal of
Agricultural Research

  • Abbreviation: Afr. J. Agric. Res.
  • Language: English
  • ISSN: 1991-637X
  • DOI: 10.5897/AJAR
  • Start Year: 2006
  • Published Articles: 6652

Full Length Research Paper

Quality levels of organic coffee seedlings in black and white nonwoven fabric (NWF) containers of various sizes

Carla Liegi Lonardoni Gomes de Oliveira
  • Carla Liegi Lonardoni Gomes de Oliveira
  • Graduate Program in Agronomy, State University of Londrina, CCA/PGAGRO, Highway Celso Garcia Cid, PR 445, Km 380, Campus, Londrina, Parana, Brazil.
  • Google Scholar
Adison Miglioranza
  • Adison Miglioranza
  • Graduate Program in Agronomy, State University of Londrina, CCA/PGAGRO, Highway Celso Garcia Cid, PR 445, Km 380, Campus, Londrina, Parana, Brazil.
  • Google Scholar

  •  Received: 01 December 2014
  •  Accepted: 17 February 2015
  •  Published: 26 February 2015


The introduction of organic production in coffee growing has demanded an increase for information on seedling production with standard of quality. Hence, the purpose of the present work was to evaluate how the amount of organic substrate in black and white nonwoven fabric (NWF) bags in four different sizes influences the quality index of Coffea arabica L. seedling produced in an organic system. The quality parameters evaluated were leaf area; number of leaves; plant height; collar diameter; dry matter of leaves, stalk, root and total. Whereas the parameters of quantity were the relation between shoot dry matter and root dry matter (RSR); the relation between shoot height and stem diameter (RHD) and the Dickson Quality Index (DQI). Seedlings produced in 1200 mL black containers presented the best results in most of the evaluated parameters. Seedlings produced in 410 mL containers presented Dickson Quality Index of 0.2, which is the index described by other authors as the adequate standard of quality for seedlings. 


Key words: Coffea arabica L., Dickson quality index, Agropote®, organic composite.


Brazil is the greatest grower, exporter and the second greatest consumer of coffee in the world (USDA, 2014). Coffee growing in Brazil has economic and social relevance. In 2013, Brazil exported around 32 million bags of coffee for U$5.27 billion, generating an estimate number of eight million jobs. Coffee cultivated area in the country is 2.311 million hectares with 6.69 billion coffee plants (CONAB, 2014; BRASIL, 2014).
In this context, coffee production without the use of chemical    pesticides   and   fertilizers in Brazil – that   is organic coffee – (Figueira and Lima-Filho, 2012) has increased each year (Della-Lucia et al., 2007), and it continues with high levels of increase (Caixeta and Pedini, 2002).
In order for the production chain of organic coffee to work properly, it is necessary that crops be healthy and economically viable. One of the basic items for the success of coffee crops is the use of good quality seedlings (Favarin et al., 2003). Villar-Salvador et al. (2004)    state   that   the   influence   of   this   quality is determined by the growth rate of a specific genotype,   which determines how adapted it is to the environmental conditions, at transplanting and stress resistance.
During production of organic seedlings, Ministry of Agriculture, Fishing and Supply (MAPA) Normative Instruction n. 007, of 17 May 1999, and Law 10831/03 determine that seeds and seedlings must come from organic systems and, in the absence of those, the grower may use products existing in the market as long as they have been previously evaluated by the certifying institution and do not include genetically modified organisms – GMO/transgenics (BRASIL, 1999; 2003).
However, due to the shortage of seeds and registered nurseries, the normative instruction still allows for the use of seeds and seedlings obtained from conventional growing methods (Moura et al., 2007), as long as the period necessary for the conversion of conventional to organic crop be waited. This way, the introduction of organic production in coffee growing demanded an increase for information on seedling production.
There are various factors that may influence the initial development of coffee growing in the field, such as the seedlings production process and, specially, the container and substrate used (Vallone et al., 2009). Amongst the containers used in conventional coffee seedling production in Brazil, one can first list black polyethylene bags and black hard plastic tubes (Vallone et al., 2010). Both types of containers present a few disadvantages, such as the contamination of the environment by the plastic bags when they are not properly discarded and, in the case of the tubes, the need for returning them to the nursery personnel.
Recently, growers started using bags made of white nonwoven fabric (NWF) called Agropote® as an alternative for the production of seedlings with standard of quality for they present favorable morphological and physiological characteristics responsible for the fast growth of seedlings.
The NWF is a material made from polypropylene and viscose based fabric (standard NBR-13370) (ABINT, 2013). Amongst its main characteristics are the facts that it is non-toxic and semipermeable, besides being classified as a biodegradable product due to be made with polypropylene in which the additive was added oxybiodegradable PDQ-H®, which degrade in a much shorter time than ordinary plastics. Its degradation time in the environment runs from six months to one year (ABINT, 2013).
Previous studies have been published by Matiello et al. (2008) and evaluated the formation and direct planting of coffee seedlings in NWF containers. Nasser et al. (2010) studied the development and quality of coffee seedlings (Coffea arabica L.) produced in conventional plastic bacs, tubes and NWF bags.
Regarding the substrate, the most common mixture in the production of coffee seedlings using conventional polyethylene bags was formed by soil (70%) and cattle manure (30%), enriched with chemical fertilizers (Dias  et al., 2009). Cunha et al. (2006) state that the substrate used must contain biological, physical, and chemical characteristics that fulfill the plant’s needs. Besides, the individual cost of the seedling must be considered in relation to its final cost (Dias et al., 2009).
Figueira and Lima-Filho (2012) state that, in organic agriculture, chemical products are substituted by byproducts that come from recycled vegetal and animal organic materials. Hence, the use of cattle, sheep and poultry manure has the potential for composing substrates to be used when preparing coffee seedlings for they are one of the most common sources of essential micro and macronutrients needed for the good development of seedlings. In one of the first technical standards adopted for coffee growing, Souza (1996) already stated that the substrate used in the formation of seedlings should be composed of soil (50%) and manure (50%).
For the organic production of coffee seedlings, the requirements for organic growing imposed by MAPA must be fulfilled. Besides, preventive measures regarding the construction and maintenance of the nurseries must be adopted so that one can get healthy and good quality seedlings (Moura et al., 2005).
The objective of the present work was to evaluate how the volume of organic substrate in white and black NWF bags influence the development and quality index of C. arabica L. seedlings produced in an organic system.
The Dickson Quality Index (DQI) is considered a good indicator amongst the parameters of quality of seedlings, especially when it takes into account the robustness and the balance in the distribution of phytomass in the seedlings. Therefore, the DQI results are important parameters to be used when evaluating the quality of seedlings (Fonseca et al., 2002).


The experiment was carried out from December 2012 to June 2013, in the seedling production sector in the Agrarian Sciences Center at the State University of Londrina (UEL), in Londrina-PR. The region is located at 23° 23’S latitude, 51° 11’W longitude and altitude of 566 m. According to the classification of Köppen, the environment is humid subtropical (Cfa).
Pre-sowing was carried out in December 2012 with seedlings of cultivar ‘Iapar 98’ at the cotyledonary-leaf stage, known as ‘orelha-de-onça’ (ear of Brazilian jaguar), which had been sown in sand beds. The seedlings were placed in raised beds in a nursery covered with shade cloths with shade percentage of 50% and equipped with an automated irrigation system of micro sprinklers of flow rate of 75 L h-1 that were run six times a day for 10 min.
The containers were made with NWF of two colors: 1) black and 2) white; of four different sizes: T1) 8 cm x 15 cm (220 mL); T2) 10 cm x 18 cm (410 mL); T3) 12 cm x 21 cm (750 mL) and T4) 14 cm x 24 cm (1200 mL). The substrate used was a mixture of 50% soil a+ 50% organic composite (mixture of cattle, poultry and sheep manure), both taken from the Farm School of UEL. Soil testing is shown in Table 1.
The experimental design was completely randomized in a factorial scheme with four sizes of NWF bags in two colors, with 4 repetitions and 30 plants per plot.  Seedlings growth and   quality evaluations started 94 days after transplanting (DAT). The following characteristics were determined: leaf area (LA) expressed in cm2, estimated with leaf area measurer LI-COR model LI 3000; b) number of leaves (NL); c) shoot height (HGT), expressed in cm, measured with a millimetric ruler, from the collar to the terminal bud; d) collar diameter (DIAM), expressed in mm, measured using a 0.01 mm precision digital caliper; e) leaves dry mass (LDM), stalk dry mass (SDM) and roots dry mass (RDM), expressed in grams, determined inside a greenhouse with forced air circulation at 75°C; f) total dry mass (TDM), expressed in grams, obtained by the sum of the dry masses of leaves, stalk and root; g) relation between shoot dry matter and root dry matter (RSR); h) relation between shoot height and stem diameter (RHD); i) Dickson Quality Index (DQI)(Figure 1), obtained through the formula of Figure 2 (Dickson et al., 1960).
The data was subject to analysis of variance by the F test and the averages were compared by the Tukey range test at 5% probability. For evaluated characteristics in each category of container color and volume, polynomial models were tested for the effect of time in days after transplanting (DAT) by means of regression analysis. The criteria for the choice of the model were the relevance by the F test at 5% probability of error that presented higher value of the coefficient of determination (R2).


The results of the analysis of variance regarding the evaluated parameters can be found in Table 2, where the relevant effect of volume and color of the containers can be observed in most of the evaluated characteristics.
Only RHD did not present relevant effect for the size of the NWF seedling heat mat, whereas for the color of the mats, parameters HGT, DIAM, RootDM, RHD and DQI did not present relevant effect. Hence, every other characteristic presented relevant interaction with the sizes and colors at 5% probability level by F test. Marana et al. (2008) when evaluating quality and growth index for coffee seedling in tubes also observed that RSR did not present relevant interaction amongst the studied substrates and doses of slow release fertilizers.
Table 3 presents the averages of the variables analyzed in seedlings considering the volume of the containers by the Tukey range test. Amongst all the evaluated characteristics, only RHD did not show relevant difference for the different volumes of NWF containers. The same was observed by Pereira et al. (2013) when RHD did not preset statistical difference on its numbers. The foresaid authors reached the average value of 7.36 for RHD and characterize such value as excessive growth for seedlings of coffee canephora in height. In the present work, RHD values vary from 6.21 to 6.46.
As a result, while observing the time in T, considering all variables in relation to the volumes of the containers, test F was carried out to determine the level of the equations. A positive linear effect was observed for characteristics DIAM and LDM, whereas for all other characteristics, the effect was quadratic positive (Figure 2 and Table 2).
The 1200 mL container presented the highest statistical difference for all characteristics, and only with DIAM, RoodDM and RSR there were no differences considering volumes 750 and 1200 mL (Tables 3, 4 and Figure 2).  
In general, all parameters showed an increase in values with the increase of the volume of the containers, the color being irrelevant. Vallone et al. (2010) evaluated different containers and substrates in the production of coffee seedlings and concluded that larger containers provide for more developed seedlings.
Gülcü et al. (2010) evaluated morphological characteristics, such as height, collar diameter, fresh and dry weight of shoot and root, and the shoot/root relations in seedlings of Juniperus  excelsa  Bieb.  in polyethylene containers with variation in length and substrate composition. The best results indicated that the greater the length of the container, the better the quality of the seedlings. Therefore, the authors concluded that the best seedlings were produces in 11 cm x 30 cm containers, and the best substrate was formed by forest soil.
The quality of the seedlings is necessary for the success of cultures that demand a growing stage in nurseries. The influence of such quality has been studied considering the performance of such seedlings in the fieldand is a consequence of the time the seedlings have lived from nursery until planting (Del Campo; Navarro; Ceacero, 2010). In this context, the concept of ‘target seedlings’, which present a minimum standard of quality in order to be planted in the field, has been discussed and applied to the eucalyptus culture (Close, 2012). There is lack of studies applied to coffee seedlings, even though coffee growing presents high importance due to the fact it is a perennial culture.
In order to evaluate the DQI considering the size of the NWF bags, the volume of 1200 mL, with greater dimensions (14 cm x 24 cm), was the one that presented the best result in relation to the index of value 0.28 (Table 3, Table 4 and Figure 2). Hunt  (1990)  recommended  as DQI standard the minimum value of 0.20. Hence, it is interesting observing the seedlings that reached such value, with a substrate value of 410 mL. Marana   et  al.  (2008)  reached  DQI valuest hat   varybetween 0.04 and 0.21 for coffee seedlings produced in tubes. Silva et al. (2012) when evaluating Eucalyptus urophylla × Eucaliptus grandis seedlings in relation to the substrates at 90 days after staking reached maximum values of DQI 0.19 with vermiculite and coconut fiber based substrate at the same proportion (1:1).
Pereira et al. (2013), when evaluating seedlings that came from four distinct nurseries located in the south of the capital of the state of Espírito Santo, reached DQI values that vary from 0.21 and 0.70. Whereas Binotto (2007), while studying the relations between growth variables and Dickson Quality Index in eucalyptus and pine seedlings reached DQI values of 0.5 for E. grandis 120 days after emergence and 0.25 for Pinus elliotti 175 days after emergence.
Regarding the colors of the NWF bags in Table 3 and Figure 3, it can be observed that black bags presented greater relevant differences for most of the parameters. Furuta (1960) was pioneer in studies relating the color of the containers with seedlings development. In his study, Flex crenata rotundifolia seedlings presented better results in light color containers.
For the interactions between the volume and color of the containers, none of the evaluated characteristics presented relevant effect (Table 2). For the interaction of the volume of the containers with the seven conducted evaluations, only RSR and RHD were not relevant, whereas all other characteristics presented relevant effect, demonstrating that the time factor (DAT) imposes differences to the growth of the plants in the different sizes of the bags. Regarding the interaction of the color with the seven conducted evaluations, only characteristics DIAM, LDM, SDM and TDM presented relevant effect. TDM values vary from 1.50 to 3.39. While Maranata et al. (2008) obtained values for the same parameter between 0.16 and 1.86; one can observe the superiority of the values obtained in seedlings produced in NWF seedling heat mats with organic substrate.
When analyzing the behavior of the functions in Graphs a and b in Figure 3 and Table 3, for the size of the containers, it can be observed that points for maximum growth were reached and correspondent to the evaluated days, which vary from 21 cm for HGT and 3.25 mm for DIAM. Such points did not influence the values for RHD so no relevant difference between the sizes existed. Binotto (2007) state that the variable height is only efficient to indicate the quality of seedlings when it is analyzed together with the collar of the diameter.

According to Graph b in Figure 3 and Table 5, it can be observed that the values for diameter  at  115 DAT  were smaller, which can be explained due to the fact of the evaluation of the work be carried out in the destructive method, always evaluating different plants at each evaluated period. Because NWF is a material of easy degradation and presenting high porosity, at the first evaluation carried out (94 DAT), it was observed that the 220 mL and 410 mL containers already presented exposed small lateral roots.
At 157 DAT, black containers of all sizes presented exposed lateral roots, whereas this fact was not observed in white containers. In NWF 220 mL bags of both colors – black and white – intertwined roots were present amongst the bags. It was also observed the presence of ‘pião-torto’, or the twisting of the main root of the coffee seedling when in contact with the bottom of the container in 220 mL and 410 mL bags.
At 199 DAT, it was observed that lateral roods in all sizes containers and independently of the color were very firm, hard and intertwined amongst the bags. At 220 DAT, only 1200 mL bags presented seedlings with the first pair of plagiotropic branches, due to its bigger volume and consequent providing the seedling with greater nutrient levels for its formation, therefore resulting in greater growth and stronger seedlings.
Due to the fact that coffee is a perennial culture, the production of healthy seedlings, well developed and with high standard of quality is a factor of extreme importance for coffee growing. Therefore, in the present work, it was observed that black 1200 mL NWF bags presented the best results for the evaluated parameters. It is important to highlight that coffee seedling in 410 mL containers presented the minimum value required by the DQI for good quality seedlings.


The authors have not declared any conflict of interest.


ABINT-Associação Brasileira das Indústrias de Não tecidos e Tecidos Técnicos (2013). Nãotecidos.
BRASIL (1999). Ministério da Agricultura, Pecuária e do Abastecimento. Instrução Normativa n° 7, de 17 de maio de 1999.
BRASIL (2003). Ministério da Agricultura, Pecuária e do Abastecimento. Lei 10831 de 23 de Dezembro de 2003.

BRASIL (2014). Ministério da Agricultura Pecuária e do Abastecimento.


Binotto AF (2007). Relationship between the growth variables and the Dickson quality index in seedlings of Eucalyptus grandis W. Hill ex Maid and Pinus elliottii var. elliotti - Engelm. Dissertação Universidade Federal de Santa Maria, Programa de Pós-Graduação em Engenharia Florestal, P. 54 f.
Caixeta IF, Pedini S (2002). Organic coffee marketing. Informe Agropecuário 23:149-152.
Close DC (2012). A review of ecophysiologically-based seedling specifications for temperate Australian eucalypt plantations. New For. 43:739-753.
CONAB–Companhia Nacional De Abastecimento (2014). Acompanhamento de Safra Brasileira de Café. Safra 2014. Segundo Levantamento. Maio. 2014. 
Cunha AM, Cunha GM, Sarmento RA, Cunha GM, Amaral JFT (2006). Effect of various substrates on the development of seedlings of Acacia sp. Revista Árvore. 30:207-214.
Della-Lucia SM, Minim VPR, Silva CHO, Minim LA (2007). Organic coffee packaging factors on consumer purchase intention. Food Sci. Technol. 27:485-491.
Del Campo AD, Navarro RM, Ceacero CJ (2010). Seedling quality and field performance of commercial stocklots of containerized holm oak (Quercus ilex) in Mediterranean Spain: an approach for establishing a quality standard. New Forests. 39:19-37.
Dias R, Melo B, Rufino MA, Silveira DL, Morais TP, Santana DG (2009). Sources and proportions of organic material for the production of coffee seedlings in plastic tubes. Ciênc. Agrotecnol. 33:758-764.
Dickson A, Leaf A, Hosner JF (1960). Quality appraisal of white spruce and white pine seedling stock in nurseries. For. Chron. 36:10-13.
Favarin JL, Costa JD, Novembre ADC, Fazuoli LC, Favarin MGG (2003). Seed characteristics in relation to their physiological potential and the quality of coffee seedlings (Coffea arabica L.). Rev. Bras. Sement. 25:13-19.
Figueira TA, Lima-Filho DO (2012). Internationalization of family production of organic coffee of the Espírito Santo/ES. Rev. Ideas 6:83-107.
Fonseca ÉP, Valéri SV, Miglioranza É, Fonseca NAN, Couto L (2002). Quality standard seedlings of Trema micrantha (L.) Blume grown under different periods of shading. Rev. Árvore 26:515-523.
Furuta T (1960). Site preparation and container type: Effects on growth of round-leavel Japanese holly. American nurserymen, 112:6-15. In: Foresty Abstracts (1961) 22:1770.

Gülcü S, Gültekin HC, Çelik S, Eser Y, Gürlevik N (2010). The Effects of different pot length and growing media on seedling quality of Crimean juniper (Juniperus excelsa Bieb.) Afr. J. Biotechnol. 9:2101-2107.


Hunt GA (1990). Effect Of Styroblock Design And Cooper Treatment On Morphology Of Conifer Seedlings. In: Target Seedling Symposium, Meeting Of The Western Forest Nursery Associations, General Technical Report Rm-200, Roseburg. Proceedings. Fort Collins: United States Department of Agriculture, Forest Service, 1990, pp.218-222.
Marana JP, Miglioranza É, Fonseca, ÉP, Kainuma RH (2008). Quality Scores and growth of coffee seedlings grown in tubes. Ciência Rural. 38:39-45.
Matiello JB, Garcia AL, Almeida PC, Andrade RJ, Ramos SV (2008). Training and direct planting coffee seedlings in containers Nonwoven Fabric. In: Congresso Brasileiro de Pesquisas Cafeeiras, 34, Caxambu, 2008. Anais...Caxambu: Mapa/Procafé, pp. 34-35.

Moura WM, Lima PC, Sano P, Condé A, Silva L, Silva T, Garcia Júnior E (2007). Methodology for organic production of coffee seedlings. Rev. Bras. Agroecol. 2:27-30.


Moura WM, Lima PC, Souza HN, Cardoso IM, Mendonça ES, Pertel J (2005). Research on agro-ecological and organic systems of family coffee in the Zona Mata Mineira. Informe Agropecuário. 26:46-75.
Nasser MD, Lima-Júnior S, Gallo PB (2010). Quality of Coffea arabica L. seedlings produced in conventional plastic bags, tubes and nonwoven. Omnia Exatas 3:7-12. 

Pereira LR, Marcilio GS, Mota FM, Sant'ana BT, Dardengo MCJD (2013). Qualidade de mudas do café Conilon Vitória produzidas em viveiros do sul capixaba. Enciclopédia Biosfera. 9:2213.


Silva RBG, Simões D, Silva MR (2012). Quality of clonal seedlings of Eucalyptus urophylla x E. grandis according to the substrate. Rev. Bras. Engenharia Agríc. Ambiental 16:297-302.
Souza SP (1966). Cultura do café. Sete Lagoas: IPEACO, 32p. (Circular, 2).

USDA – United States Department of Agriculture (2014). Coffee: World Markets and Trade. June 2014. P. 5.


Vallone HS, Guimarães RJ, Mendes ANG, Souza CAS, Dias FP, Carvalho AM (2009). Containers and substrates in the production of seedlings and initial development of coffee after planting. Ciênc. Agrotecnol. 33:1327-1335.
Vallone HS, Guimarães RJ, Mendes ANG, Souza CAS, Cunha RL, Dias FP (2010). Different containers and substrates in the production of coffee seedlings. Ciênc. Agrotecnol. 34:55-60.

Villar-Salvador P, Planelles R, Enriquez E, Pe-uelas-Rubira J (2004). Nursery cultivation regimes, plant functional attributes and field performance relationships in the Mediterranean oak Quecus ilex L. For. Ecol. Manage. 196:257-266.