African Journal of
Agricultural Research

  • Abbreviation: Afr. J. Agric. Res.
  • Language: English
  • ISSN: 1991-637X
  • DOI: 10.5897/AJAR
  • Start Year: 2006
  • Published Articles: 6544

Full Length Research Paper

Coinoculation of rhizobia and mycorrhiza in cowpea beans (Vigna unguiculata (L.) Walp) in Calixto García Municipality, Cuba

Sebastián Zayas Infante
  • Sebastián Zayas Infante
  • Municipal University Center of Calixto García, Holguín University, Cuba
  • Google Scholar
Maura Isabel Rodríguez Palma
  • Maura Isabel Rodríguez Palma
  • Department of Economy, Faculty of Economics and Adminstration, Holguín University, Cuba
  • Google Scholar
Heriberto Vargas Rodríguez
  • Heriberto Vargas Rodríguez
  • Department of Water and Soils, the Agrarian University, Havana Province, Cuba
  • Google Scholar
María Caridad Nápoles Garcia
  • María Caridad Nápoles Garcia
  • National Institute of Agricultural Sciences (INCA), Cuba.
  • Google Scholar
Irina Reyes Martínez
  • Irina Reyes Martínez
  • Municipal University Center of Calixto García, Holguín University, Cuba
  • Google Scholar
Reynaldo Guzmán Paez
  • Reynaldo Guzmán Paez
  • Municipal University Center of Calixto García, Holguín University, Cuba
  • Google Scholar
Carmelo Damián Agüero Pintado
  • Carmelo Damián Agüero Pintado
  • Municipal University Center of Calixto García, Holguín University, Cuba
  • Google Scholar

  •  Received: 19 October 2020
  •  Accepted: 13 April 2021
  •  Published: 31 July 2021


The research goal is to evaluate the rhizobia and mycorrhiza application on Cowpea bean (Vigna unguiculata L) cv. Carita Blanco growth. The experiments were developed at Calixto García municipality, Cuba. It was conducted from April to June 2020, on brown Sialitic soil without carbonate. This design was a random block with three treatments (Control, Rhizobium and Rhizobium + Mycorrhizas). It entailed indicators measurement during ten days and after seeds plantation. The indicators measured were plant length (cm), number of trifoliate leaves, the diameter of the stem base (mm), number of nodules per plant, as well as yield and its components, at the moment of harvest. Statistic helped to analyze data by one-way analysis of variance, followed by Duncan's multiple range test. Hence, the statistic professional program SPSS, version 20 for Windows was implemented. The Rhizobium and Mycorrhiza co-inoculation showed the best results for growth and yield indicators.

Key words: Biofertilizers, rhizobia, mycorrhizas, cowpea beans, inoculation, brown sialitic soils.



In underdeveloped tropical areas, the search for sustainable alternatives to reduce food dependency indicates a group of tropical grain legumes that could be constituents of the protein component needed for human and livestock diets. Current agriculture greatly produces grain legumes because of their nutritional qualities, their commercial demand, diversity of consumption along with healing properties and economic environmental importance. The cowpea (Vigna unguiculata (L.) Walp) is easy to raise and harvest. It naturally adapts to the tropical ecosystem. Likewise, it is very nutritional and widely disseminated in the tropics (Boscán, 1987; Labarca et al., 1999; Báez and Hernández, 2016).

This crop acquires more and more importance within the field of research (Saldarriaga, 2015). It has a high content of protein, iron, and zinc. Generally, small farmers cultivate this grain also for economy reasons (Tatis et al., 2017). In Cuba, it is a grain of wide agricultural use, the economic importance of it comprises two fundamental reasons: (a) it constitutes a source of vegetable protein for animal and human consumption and (b) its foliage frequently serves as a green manure (Gómez et al., 2006). The national production of grain legumes still does not satisfy consumer needs, due to the influence of various factors that limit its production. The high price of chemical fertilizers, as well as their high environmental impact, gives room for the search in order to present alternatives that help to satisfy the nutritional requirements of this crop in the country.

In this sense, legume is an option because it is reported as a rustic species that can be found in adverse environments and with tolerance to drought, high temperature, heavy metals, and saline stress. However, it can also yield a considerable amount of nitrogen (150 kg N ha-1) of symbiotic fixation to the ecosystem (Hernández et al., 2015; Gómez et al., 2017; López-Alcocer et al., 2017; Aguilar et al., 2019). The Carita Blanco variety is a prevailing Cuban grain; although, other varieties are grown but on a smaller scale, such as chickpea beans, Tomeguín eggs, corn beans, among others (Escalona, 2002). Holguín province has around 4000 ha per year to harvest this crop. Therefore, this province is the main producer of this gran in the latest years. There, Velazco is an area that treasures a very (Domínguez, 2012). On the other hand, the benefits of bio-fertilizers favor the increasing absorption of nutrients and protecting the crop from the attack of pathogens. Additionally, it furthers growth and crop yielding (Otaiku et al., 2019). It is worth mentioning that bacteria of the rhizobia family can induce in the roots of legumes the formation of specialized structures called nodules, within which atmospheric N2, which is very stable and relatively inert. It reduces to ammonium ions (NH4+), easily assimilated by most plant species (Llerena, 2017; Thuijsman, 2017). In Calixto García municipality, bean production is generally affected by some problems. For instance, loss of the productive capacity of the soils, inadequate soil management due to excess of chemical fertilizers and the use of water with high salinity for irrigation. Moreover, low yielding in cowpea bean production and limitations in the availability of chemical fertilizers to meet the requirements of the crop play their role. That is why the research aims at the evaluation of the effectiveness of the application of rhizobia and Ecomic (AMF) in the growth of the cowpea bean crop (V. unguiculata (L.) Walp), variety of Carita Blanco in Calixto García.


Description of the study site

Researchers from the Municipal University Center of Calixto García led the study during the months of April-June, 2020. The study was developed in the rural area of La Alegría, which is located in Buenaventura, Calixto García municipality, Holguín province. It is a place at the eastern end of Cuba (Figure 1), geographically located at 20° 52' 27" N latitude and at 76° 39' 03" W longitude and with an altitude of 104 m above sea level, these data were determined by SAS.PLANET software version 190707.10011 estimated height according to SRTM 3 with a precision of 90 m.

The annual average temperature is 25.6°C and rainfall ranges between 800 and 1200 mm per year. The behavior of the meteorological variables of rainfalls and high and low temperatures during the development of the research is presented in Figure 2.

Soil type and fundamental characteristics

The experiment was carried out on a Salty brown soil with carbonates (Hernández et al., 2015) with a pH (H2O) of 6.6. The potentiometric method helped to determine it. The method also helped to notice that the soil is slightly acidic to neutral. Therefore, it is considered acceptable for the development and growth of the crop. The phosphorus content is 6.4 The Oniani methods allow the determination of phosphorus. The extraction was simpler with H2SO4.  Carbon-Nitrogen ratio was of 7.6. The organic matter content rate was of 2.3%; which was determined through Walkley-Black method, d15N 10.8% was also noticed. In general terms, the analysis was developed in line with the methodology presented by Paneque et al. (2010). That is why, it is considered to have a too low average fertility. The clay fraction predominates in the soil. Based on the characteristics of the soil, it is considered appropriate for the cultivation of cowpea beans.

Soil preparation, treatments, and experimental design

Soil preparation was carried out with minimum tillage, breaking, crossing, cultivator pass, and furrowing, with animal traction. The cultivar Carita Blanco of the cowpea bean was used, the sowing was carried out at a rate of three seeds per hole at a distance of 0.15 m. When the plants sprouted and had an average height between 10 and 15 cm, each plot was thinned to leave only 2 plants per hole. At 40 days after sowing the crop (DDS), the following growth variables were evaluated: plant height (cm), a measuring tape was used for this; the number of leaves was performed by counting the diameter of the stem base (mm) for which a caliper was used; and the number of total nodules was developed by the plants in each treatment by counting. At the time of harvest, the yield components were evaluated: number of legumes per plant (in 15 plants per plot) by counting, number of grains per legume (mean of 20 legumes) by counting, the average mass of 100 grains (g) for which a digital scale with a capacity of 2610 g and a precision of 0.01 g was used, and the yield per unit area was calculated based on the mass of the grains harvested per plot. The treatments evaluated in the experiments are shown in Table 1.

A randomized block experimental design with three treatments and three replications were used with plots of 2.80 m × 4.0 m (11.20 m2). The inoculants used on the seeds were Azofert®, Rizobiumfreirei PRF-81 strain, with a concentration of 2.3 × 1010 CFU mL-1 and a dose of 200 mL-1 for 50 kg of seeds, and EcoMic®, based on arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi (AMF) of the species Glomus intraradices, at a dose of 7.5 kg for  50 kg of seed, both supplied by the National Institute of Agricultural Sciences (INCA). The sowing was carried out on June 3, 2020. The rows were 4 m long, with a separation of 0.70 m. Four rows were planted per plot with a total plot area of ??11.20 m2. A separation of 1 m between blocks and 2 m between treatments was used. Fertilizers were not applied in the experiment, registering a slight attack of Aphis cracivora 40 days after sowing, which was controlled as established in the technical instructions for this crop in Cuba. Weeding was carried out at 15 and 45 days after sowing.

Growth parameters, yield and their components

"La Jíquima" Meteorological Station located within the boundaries of Calixto García Municipality provided the values of the meteorological variables. The blooming started 38 days later. It was an irregular event in the different blocks of the experiment. At 40 days after sowing (DDS), 10 plants were randomly taken for each replica, the growth variables were evaluated: plant height (cm), number of leaves, the diameter of the stem base (mm), and the number of total nodules developed by plants. One day before harvest, 10 plants were selected per replica with a total of 30 for each treatment in the central rows. The objective was to evaluate the number of legumes per plant, number of grains per legume, and the mass of 100 grains. In the same way, we proceeded to calculate the yield in kg.ha-1. Once results came out, an economic assessment was made from the cost-benefit ratio and the profits achieved in each treatment.

Statistical analysis of the data

The data corresponding to the growth variables: plant height (cm), number of leaves, the diameter of the stem base (mm) and the number of total nodules of a plant, as well as yielding and its components were subject to a simple classification analysis of variance (ANOVA). A significance level of 5% came out. The statistical program SPSS, version 20.0 for Windows was worth implementing here. With the results of  these  analyses,  tables  and graphs were devised that help to understand the causal relationship of the different inoculums and their combination and meteorological variables with the agricultural yielding of the cowpea bean in Calixto García municipality at the eastern region of Cuba.


The behavior of the growth variables evaluated at 40 DDS and according to each treatment, is shown in Table 2.

Height of the plant

It is observed that the height of the plants shows differences in the treatments that implied the application of Rhizobium and the joint inoculation of Rhizobium and Mycorrhizae. Concerning the control, reaching the treatment II (Rhizobium + Mycorrhizal) the highest values ??with 63.5 cm. This behavior confirms the importance of the combined use of fungal and bacterial biofertilizers to improve the plant response. These results are similar to those obtained in previous studies carried out when evaluating the inoculation of Rhizobium, Mycorrhizae, and the combination of these inocula in the cultivation of common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) in the province of Matanzas (Liriano et al., 2012). Likewise, in studies carried out at the National Institute of Agricultural Sciences (INCA), Corbera and Nápoles (2011) showed significant responses between treatments, standing out, mainly for the harvest stage. This is a treatment where the joint inoculation of biofertilizers was carried out when evaluating the joint application of Rhizobium and Mycorrhizae in soybean cultivation.

The number of leaves

The number of leaves presents significant differences between the evaluated treatments, with 36.1 leaves. The co-inoculation with Rhizobium and Mycorrhizae showed the best results.

These outcomes are a response of the noticeable influence of biofertilizers in the supply of nitrogen and phosphorus to the vegetal. Other aspects that had to do with such outcomes are the increasing content of organic matter of soil and the increasing absorption capacity of the plant.

These results coincide with studies completed in other areas of the country where the highest values ??in this indicator are reported in the treatment in which the simple inoculation of Rhizobium and Mycorrhizal was carried out when evaluating the effect of these biofertilizers in the cultivation of common beans (Liriano et al., 2012). Similar results were obtained in the region of Saltillo, Coahuila in a study done based on the inoculation with Rhizobium in beans,   which  reported  that  in  the  inoculated  plants a greater number of leaves was noticed along with a better growth in the plant (Aguilar et al., 2019).

Stem base diameter

The diameter of the stem base does not show a significant difference between the inoculation with Rhizobium and the co-inoculation of Rhizobium and Mycorrhizae, corresponding to these treatments with 7.6 and 8.1 mm, respectively, the highest values, which differ significantly with the treatment used as a control. These results match those reached in previous investigations about common beans. The highest values ??in this indicator were obtained in the treatments where the co-inoculation of Rhizobium and Mycorrhizae were used in combination (Liriano et al., 2012). Similar results were achieved by Mexican researchers when evaluating this indicator in bean plants inoculated with Rhizobium in the Saltillo area, Coahuila (Aguilar et al., 2019).

The number of nodules per plant

The results obtained for the variable number of nodules per plant show significant differences between the control and the rest of the treatments. It reached the highest values ??where Rhizobium and the combination of Rhizobium with Mycorrhizal were applied with 16.4 and 17.8 nodules per plant respectively; highlighting the marked difference between these treatments and the control in which nodule formation was hardly observed.

The low emission of nodules in the controlling treatment is connected with the lack of a boost for the emission of these structures. It corroborates how beneficial micro-organisms are for the improvement and developed of this plantation.

There were no differences between the rhizobia treatment and the combination with AMF. Similar results in this variable have been indicated in the crops of common beans and soybeans when using the inoculation of the seeds with Rhizobium and its combination with arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi (AMF) (Rebeschini et al., 2014, Nápoles et al., 2014). In agricultural soils, the Rhizobium-legume association is considered the most important source of N2, since it has been reported that in nodulated legumes, under certain environmental conditions (soils poor in nitrogen), they can fix up to 100 kg N2/ha/year, being this mechanism capable of supplying the Nitrogen demand to satisfy the most important nutritional needs of the plant (FAO, 1995; Saidi et al., 2010; Nebiyu et al., 2014; Hernández et al., 2015; Ndalira et al., 2020). Similarly, implemented studies in intercropping systems of cassava with legumes in Badeggi, Nigeria report a significant contribution of this practice on the content of nutrients in the soil; specifically, the content of organic carbon, nitrogen, and available phosphorus (Gbanguba et al., 2020).

The rises triggered by the co-inoculation of de Rhizobium and Mycorrhizal in the evaluated growing variables demonstrate the capacity of the bean plantation to develop a double symbiosis Rhizobium-arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi (AMF).

Yielding and its components

When  analyzing the effect of the treatments on the yielding and yielding component variables (Figure 3), an increase in the results of these variables is generally observed in the treatments where biofertilizers were used concerning the control.

Number of legumes per plant

In the variables of grain yield and its components, the number of legumes per plant presents significant differences between treatments, observing that the highest results were obtained with the combined inoculation of Rhizobium and Mycorrhizal with 30.2 legumes. It differs significantly from the rest of the treatments, followed by simple inoculation with Rhizobium with 21.1 legumes per plant. There is a significant disparity from each other and the control. These results are similar to those that came out in previous studies where this indicator showed the highest values ??of legumes per plant in those treatments where soybeans were inoculated with both biofertilizers (Corbera and Napoles, 2011). Other quests found that the number of legumes per plant showed noticeable increases with the application of Rhizobium at the moment of evaluating its application in varieties of common bean under water stress contexts (Estrada et al., 2017).

The number of grains per legume

This indicator shows that 9.05 comes out from the control with the implementation of Rhizobium 12.15. Concerning the joint co-inoculation of Rhizobium and Mycorrhizal, there is a 14.62 average grains per legume, respectively. These results match those obtained by other studies where an increase in the number of grains per legume in common beans is observed with the application of Rhizobium (Estrada et al., 2017). Likewise, Tatis et al. (2017) got similar outcomes. They evaluated cowpea bean genotypes. They obtained values ??for the number of seeds per legume that ranged between 10.66 and 13.47 in Colombia.

The average mass of 100 grains

As regard to the average mass of 100 grains, the results indicate that 12.9 g were obtained in the control; with the inoculation of Rhizobium as 16.8 g, while the combination of Rhizobium and Mycorrhizal as 18.4 g, respectively. These results differ from those obtained in earlier research done by Corbera and Napoles (2011). Such results revealed that when evaluating the mass of 1000 grains in the soybean crop, no significant differences were observed between treatments. It indicates that this variable in the crop was little influenced by the application of the evaluated products.

Subsequent studies found that the indicators legume length, legume width, number of seeds per legume, the mass of seeds per plant, and mass of 100 seeds displayed considerable increases with the application of Rhizobium at evaluating its application in varieties of common bean in water stress contexts (Estrada et al., 2017).


As a result of the growth and development of the crop, the grain yield also indicated conspicuous differences between treatments, highlighting, in the same way, those where Rhizobium and Mycorrhizal were inoculated in a simple and combined way. Hence, it presented increases in yields of 43.06% for the cultivar studied with the control.

The yield shows a meaningful difference between the control and the treatments (simple inoculation with Rhizobium and the combination of Rhizobium and Mycorrhizal). It obtained 0.97 and 1.17 t ha-1, respectively, observing a clear tendency to increase the yield when biofertilizers were applied. The control showed the lowest yieldings with 0.63 t ha-1. This yielding behavior links itself to the increase in the mass of the grains, the number of legumes per plant, and the number of grains per legume in each treatment. Recent studies in the cultivation of common bean developed in the north of Tanzania corroborated increases in yield by determining the optimal planting density for cultivation under various doses of phosphoric fertilization (Kiriba et al., 2020).

The result obtained in the yielding components shows that the best results appear with the co-inoculation of Rhizobium + Mycorrhizal in the conditions in which the experiment was developed. It presents a close relationship with the rest of the variables analyzed.

Hernández and Cuevas (2003), Hernández (2008) and Ramos et al. (2013) agree that the combined use of Rhizobium and Mycorrhizal optimizes the process of fixation of atmospheric nitrogen, the absorption of nutritive elements, and therefore plant development is stimulated by increasing the productive potential of plants. The joint implementation of Azofert (Rhizobium) along with the arbuscular mycorrhizal G. intraradices has an effect on this particular bean plantation. Such effect is revealed in the yielding of grain number as a fundamental variable. It displayed a positive response to the study of context and the assessed plantation. Obviously, there were increases in the production of this bean. It favors a biotechnological management as an effective nutritional alternative for the development of this plantation.

Economic valuation

The economic evaluation of the results achieved in each of the treatments is shown in Table 3. To plant a hectare of bean, 50 kg of seeds is required. In order to inoculate this quantity of seeds 200 mL of Azofert is required. Then, 34.00 CUP are needed at the national market. To inoculate the same quantity of seeds with Ecomic, 7.50 kg of this product is required and it takes 8.00-CUP kg-1 in the national market.

When it comes to analyzing the correlation between investment and benefit in each of the treatments, there is a rise in sales that reports an income of 2 318.80 and 3682.80 CUP, respectively, both using biofertilizers. To attain these levels there are alternatives; for example, the use of nitrogen fertilizer. It requires 40 kg ha-1 that costs 40.00 CUC at the foreign market, that is to say 400.00 CUP according to the Cuban exchanging rate. However, national biofertilizers produced at the National Institute of Farm Sciences seem to be a better option. It is  cheaper because it only costs 34.00 CUP of Azofert and 42.00 CUP of EcoMic®. The implementation of these biofertilizers reduces the expenses at a 91% for Azofert and 76.5% in a merging of Azofert and Mycorrhizal. Therefore, the combination of both biofertilizers is the most fitting alternative in terms of economy. Thus, the profit is just over 3 588.80 CUP because the production levels are higher. Subsequently, chemical-based fertilizers are disposed of due to the natural and ecofriendly values of biofertilizers.


The results already presented in this paper suggest an effective plant-microorganism association, considering the simple inoculation and co-inoculation of Azofert and EcoMic® as a viable, sustainable, and ecological alternative for the production of the cowpea bean crop. In general, the co-inoculation of Azofert and EcoMic® showed the best results in the growth variables evaluated, as well as in the performance components.

The use of biofertilizers is an alternative that allows the achievement of better economic results and a reduction in expenses for the purchase of chemical fertilizers.


The authors have not declared any conflict of interests.


Aguilar Ramírez JO, Gallegos Morales G, Hernández Castillo FD, Cepeda Siller M, Sánchez Aspeytia D (2019). Incidencia y severidad del tizón común en plantas de frijol inoculados con Rhizobium phaseoli. Revista Mexicana de Ciencias Agrícolas 10(2):325-336. Texcoco feb./mar.  


Báez A, Hernández CA (2016). Estudio del rendimiento de cultivares de frijol Caupí (Vignaunguiculata (L.) Walp.) en diferentes épocas de siembra en Camajuaní, Cuba. RECyT, Año 18 / Suplemento Nº 1. pp. 11-18.



Boscán D (1987). Generalidades del frijol. En: Caraota y frijol. FUSAGRI pp. 9-12.


Corbera GJ, Nápoles MC (2011). Evaluación de la inoculación conjunta Bradyrhizobiumelkanii-Hongos MA y la aplicación de un bioestimulador del crecimiento vegetal en soya, cultivada en época de primavera. Cultivos Tropicales 32(4):13-19.



Domínguez GJA (2012). Evaluación del rendimiento productivo de dos Variedades de Frijol Caupí del género Vigna unguiculata en la UBPC ¨Otmero Peña¨ Tesis en opción al título de ingeniero Agrónomo. Universidad de Holguín, Cuba 33 p.


Escalona CN (2002). Comportamiento Agronómico de variedades de fríjol Caupí (Vignaunguiculata L. Walp) en dos Municipios de la provincia de Holguín / C. N. Escalona, Evelio García Sánchez. Tesis de Maestría en Producción Vegetal. Universidad de Granma, Granma, Cuba 98 p.


Estrada Prado W, Chávez Suárez L, Jerez Mompie E, Nápoles García MC, Sosa Rodríguez A, Cordoví Domínguez C, Celeiro Rodríguez F (2017). Efecto del Azofert® en el rendimiento de variedades de frijol común (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) en condiciones de déficit hídrico. Centro Agrícola 44(3):1-6.



Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) (1995). Manual técnico de la fijación del nitrógeno. Organización de las Naciones Unidas para la Agricultura y la Alimentación, Roma, Italia pp. 10-35.



Gbanguba AU, Daniya E, Kolo MG, Ibrahim PA, Ismaila U, Umar U (2020). Effects of pre-rice cassava/legume intercrops and weed management practices on weed dynamics and yield of low land rice in Badeggi, Nigeria. African Journal of Agricultural Research 16(6):829-842. Disponible en




Gómez LA, Dueñas G, Martínez A (2006). Fijación simbiótica del N2 en dos genotipos de Caupí determinados cultivados en suelo Ferralítico Rojo con baja fertilidad. 10p. Available at


Gómez Padilla E, Ruiz-Díez B, Fajardo S, Eichler-Loebermann B, Samson R, Van Damme P, López Sánchez R, Fernández-Pascual M (2017). Caracterización de rizobios aislados de nódulos de frijol Caupí, en suelos salinos de Cuba. Cultivos Tropicales 38(4):39-49.



Hernández A, Pérez JM, Bosch D, Castro N (2015). Clasificación de los Suelos de Cuba 2015. Ediciones INCA, La Habana, Cuba. 93p.


Hernández AF (2008). La coinoculación Glomus hoi-like- Bradyrhizobium japonicum en la producción de soya (Glycine max) variedad Verónica para semilla. Cultivos Tropicales 29(4):41-45. 



Hernández G, Sánchez M, Toscano V, Méndez N (2015). Efecto de inóculo de Rhizobium en frijol común (Phaseolus vulgaris L.). Agronomía Mesoamericana 10(1):49-59.



Hernández M, Cuevas F (2003). The effect of inoculating with arbuscular mycorrhiza and Bradyrhizobium strains on soybean (Glycine max (L.) Merrill) crop development. Cultivos Tropicales, 24(2):19-21.



Kiriba DS, Msaky JW, Mahenge NS, Samwel P, Kessy GA, Kadeghe E, Binagwa PH (2020). Yield responses of bush bean varieties to different planting densities and rates of phosphorous fertilizer. African Journal of Agricultural Research 15(1):40-48. Available at: DOI: 10.5897/AJAR2019.14078.


Labarca M, Mora S, Sila S, Bracho B, Castro R, Mavares O, Higuera A (1999). Optimización de riego en frijol Vigna unguiculata en suelos de la altiplanicie de Maracaibo. Revista de la Facultad de Agronomia 16(1):306-317.


Liriano R, Núñez DB, Barceló R (2012). Efecto de la aplicación de Rhizobium y Mycorriza en el crecimiento del frijol (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) variedad CC-25-9 negro. Centro Agrícol 39(4):17-20.


Llerena HAB (2017). Efecto de la coinoculación de Hongos Micorrízicos Arbusculares y Bradyrhizobium japonicum sobre la producción de Soya (Glycine max (L.) Merr) en la provincia Los Ríos, República del Ecuador. Tesis presentada en opción al grado científico de doctor en Ciencias Agrícolas. Universidad Agraria de la Habana « Fructuoso Rodríguez Pérez », Mayabeque, Cuba 133 p.


López-Alcocer JJ, Lépiz-Ildefonso R, González-Eguiarte DR, Rodríguez-Macias R, López-Alcocer E, Olalde-Portugal V (2017). Caracterización morfológica y bioquímica de cepas de Rhizobium colectadas en frijol común silvestre y domesticado. Fitotecnia Mexicana 40(1):73-81.




Nápoles MC, González G, Ferreira A, Rossi A, Hernández I y Costales D (2014). Efecto de diferentes inoculantes sobre la nodulación de la Soya cultivada en condiciones de estrés. Cultivos Tropicales 35(4):45-51.



Ndalira W, Odhiambo JA, Basweti EA (2020). Evaluation of cowpea rust disease incidence and severity on selected cowpea genotypes in Western Kenya. African Journal of Agricultural Research 16(7):1015-1024.




Nebiyu A, Huygens D, Upadhayay HR, Diels J, Boeckx P (2014). Importance of correct B value determination to quantify biological N2 fixation and N balances of faba beans (Vicia faba L.) via 15 N natural abundance. Biology and Fertility of Soils 50(3):1-11.




Otaiku AA, Mmom PC, Ano AO (2019). Biofertilizer Impacts on Cassava (Manihot Esculenta Crantz) Rhizosphere: Crop Yield and Growth Components, Igbariam, Nigeria. World Journal of Agriculture and Soil Science 3(5). ISSN: 2641-6379. .




Paneque VM, Calaña JM, Calderón M, Borges Y, Hernandez TV, Cartucho M (2010). Manual de técnicas analíticas para análisis de suelo, foliar, abonos orgánicos y fertilizantes químicos. Ediciones INCA, La Habana, Cuba 160 p. ISBN: 978-959-7023-51-7


Ramos L, Arozarena NJ, Daza Y, García R, Telo L, Ramírez M, Lescaille J, Martín, GM (2013). Hongos Micorrízicos Arbusculares, Azotobacter chroococcum, Bacillus megatherium Y FitoMas-E: una alternativa eficaz para la reducción del consumo de fertilizantes minerales en Psidium guajava, L. var. Enana Roja cubana. Cultivos Tropicales 34(1):5-10.



Rebeschini AC, Mazzuchelli R, de Araujo ASF, de Araujo FF (2014). Nitrogen application and inoculation with Rhizobium tropici on common bean in the fall/Winter. Academic Journal 9(42):3156-3163. 


Saidi M, Itulia FM, Aguyo N, Mushenga PM (2010). Yields and profitability of dual-purposeSole Cowpea and cowpea-maize intercrop as influenced by leaf harvesting. Journal of Agriculture and Biology Science 5(5):65-71.


Saldarriaga de Guimaraes MA (2015). Efecto de la posición de siembra dentro del surco en tres variedades de frijol Caupí (Vignaunguiculata L. Walp). Tesis a la facultad de agronomía para optar el título de ingeniero Agrónomo. Universidad Nacional de Piura, Perú 100 p.



Tatis HA, Camacho ME, Ayala CC (2017). Adaptabilidad y estabilidad fenotípica en cultivares de fríjol Caupí en el caribe húmedo Colombiano. Biotecnología en el sector agropecuario y agroindustrial 15(2):14-22.


Thuijsman ES (2017). Light and nutrient capture by common bean (Phaseolus vulgaris L.) and maize (Zea mays L.) in the Northern Highlands of Tanzania. Tesis para optar por el título de máster en Agricultura orgánica y Agroecología. Universidad de Wageningen, Países Bajos.