African Journal of

  • Abbreviation: Afr. J. Biotechnol.
  • Language: English
  • ISSN: 1684-5315
  • DOI: 10.5897/AJB
  • Start Year: 2002
  • Published Articles: 12485

Full Length Research Paper

Extreme resistance to late blight disease by transferring 3 R genes from wild relatives into African farmer-preferred potato varieties

Ethel N. Webi
  • Ethel N. Webi
  • International Potato Center, Biosciences East and Central Africa (BecA-ILRI hub), P. O. Box 25171-00603 Nairobi, Kenya.
  • Google Scholar
Kariuki Daniel
  • Kariuki Daniel
  • Department of Biochemistry, Jomo Kenyatta University of Agriculture and Technology, P. O. Box 62000-00200 Nairobi, Kenya.
  • Google Scholar
Kinyua Johnson
  • Kinyua Johnson
  • Department of Biochemistry, Jomo Kenyatta University of Agriculture and Technology, P. O. Box 62000-00200 Nairobi, Kenya.
  • Google Scholar
Njoroge Anne
  • Njoroge Anne
  • International Potato Center, Biosciences East and Central Africa (BecA-ILRI hub), P. O. Box 25171-00603 Nairobi, Kenya.
  • Google Scholar
Ghislain Marc
  • Ghislain Marc
  • International Potato Center, Biosciences East and Central Africa (BecA-ILRI hub), P. O. Box 25171-00603 Nairobi, Kenya.
  • Google Scholar
Magembe Eric
  • Magembe Eric
  • International Potato Center, Biosciences East and Central Africa (BecA-ILRI hub), P. O. Box 25171-00603 Nairobi, Kenya.
  • Google Scholar

  •  Received: 13 May 2019
  •  Accepted: 29 August 2019
  •  Published: 30 September 2019


Three late blight resistance (R) genes from wild potato species were transferred as a stack into the farmer-preferred varieties ‘Tigoni’ and ‘Shangi’. Transgenic events were tested by detached-leaf assays (DLA) and whole-plant assays (WPA) with isolates of Phytophthora infestans using 20,000 sporangia / mL inoculum. For the first DLA, 9 out of 13 ‘Tigoni’ and 10 out of 12 ‘Shangi’ transgenic events had scores below 3% of leaf affected area. 17 of the 19 transgenic events with low scores were subjected to a second DLA using two different P. infestans isolates. 8 of them exhibited extreme LB resistance while the remaining 9 transgenic events showed hypersensitive response (HR). 6 transgenic events (2 ‘Tigoni’ and 4 ‘Shangi’) with extreme resistance by DLA were subjected to WPA and they all exhibited extreme resistance to LB. Hence, this study demonstrates that a simple DLA predicts high level of resistance to late blight. R gene expression analysis in 18 transgenic events showed different transgenic events exhibiting different levels of expression in the three genes. However, that pathogen induction and / or high R gene expression are necessary for extreme resistance when transgenic events bear a stack of three R genes was not observed.


Key words: Detached-leaf assay, late blight, Phytophthora infestans, resistance.


Agriculture is the mainstay of African nations where 48% of the total African population and almost 70% in East Africa rely on agriculture for their livelihood (NEPAD, 2013). Therefore, the African Union (AU) chose to make agriculture one of the pillars of the  New  Partnership  for African Development (NEPAD). It is geared towards contribution to development goals such as poverty eradication through improved crop production, job creation and boosting Africa trade and investments. Potato  (Solanum  tuberosum L.), being the world’s fourth
largest crop after maize, wheat and rice is universally significant (IYP, 2008). The crop is cultivated in tropical and subtropical regions of the world and can grow from sea level up to over 4,000 m above sea level (Wurster, 1977). Production and consumption have increased significantly in recent years mainly through expansion of cultivated areas (Devaux et al., 2014).
Processing of potatoes into food products has become increasingly important in African urban areas. Therefore, potato is a significant crop in Africa and its year-round production a common feature in many African countries which gives it a great potential for providing food security. At present, developing countries produce more potatoes than developed countries. In Sub-Saharan Africa, India and China, production continues to rise with the total production being close to 250 million tons up from 35 million tons in 1960 (Haverkort and Struik, 2015). In Kenya, potato is the second most important food and cash crop mainly grown by small-scale farmers (Laititi, 2014; Muthoni et al., 2013). It provides nutritional benefits such as vitamin C and provides employment for more than 2.5 million people (Kaguongo et al., 2013). Varieties available in Kenya include ‘Shangi’, ‘Tigoni’, ‘Asante’, ‘Ambition’, ‘Rudolf’, ‘Kenya Mavuno’ among others. The first two are some of the most preferred varieties in Kenya, due to their, taste, versatile use, short dormancy period and fast maturity of approximately three months (NPCK, 2015).
Late blight (LB) caused by the oomycete Phytophthora infestans, is the most devastating disease of potato in the world. It is a major biotic constraint to production and has been observed by farmers as a problem that causes heavy economic losses that can be as high as 90% if the disease strikes early in the growing season (Ssengooba and Hakiza, 1999).  P. infestans is an economically important pathogen that was responsible for the Irish potato famine in 1840 which led to the death of 1 million people and the migration of 1.5 million others (Schumann and D’Arcy, 2005). Loss of potatoes due to LB in the world has been estimated at 5.2 billion euros per annum (Haverkort et al., 2009). Susceptible potato varieties require fungicide application as the only option to control the disease. However, the cost of fungicide, machinery and labor are unaffordable to resource poor farmers. Furthermore, fungicide resistance is on the rise and the population structure of P. infestans in East Africa is changing (Njoroge et al., 2016).
LB infection can be delayed by the use of certified seeds and through crop rotation (Hannukkala et al., 2007); but the most cost-effective way to control any plant disease is by host resistance since this offers prevention from the disease. Thus, conventional breeding has long been pursued for the development of host resistance. However, it takes several decades to obtain resistant cultivars from the first cross with resistant wild species and these varieties still suffer from linkage drag of undesirable alleles from wild relatives (Haverkort et al., 2009). Resistant cultivars often use single R gene-based resistance which is rapidly overcome by virulent P. infestans strains that have a compatible interaction with the resistant plants (Vleeshouwers et al., 2000).
Several R genes against P. infestans originating from a wide variety of wild species have been isolated in the last decade such as RB (same as Rpi-blb1) and Rpi-blb2 genes from Solanum bulbocastanum, a Mexican wild species, and Rpi-vnt1.1 from S. venturii, an Argentinean wild species. The latter has three similar allelic variants; Rpi-vnt1.1, Rpi-vnt1.2 and Rpi-vnt1.3. These R genes confer extreme resistance to P. infestans but have not been extensively used in potato breeding due to the time lag to produce acceptable varieties and the short-lasting resistance mediated by single R genes (Vleeshouwers et al., 2011). Consequently, no virulent strains of P. infestans have been selected which make these genes likely to confer a longer lasting resistance than those previously introduced into potato varieties such as those from S. demissum.
Numerous R genes have been cloned and can be stacked in existing potato varieties which would result in new LB resistant varieties, in a much shorter time with longer lasting resistance and no linkage drag. This strategy has been explored and achieved extreme resistance to late blight disease (Zhu et al., 2012; Ghislain et al., 2018). Interestingly, Haesaert et al., (2015) showed that by stacking several R genes (Rpi-sto1, Rpi-vnt1.1 and Rpi-blb3), complete resistance to P. infestans was achieved in the field whereas ‘Desiree’ transgenic events transformed with single R genes only achieved partial resistance. Though their study covered only 2 to 3 years, plants with stacked R genes appeared more stable than the single R gene plants which got infected with virulent isolates during their field experiments.
Each of the three R genes, belonging to the nucleotide-binding site (NBS) and leucine rich repeats (LRR) domains, expresses proteins that recognize P. infestans AVR-BLB1, AVR-BLB2 and AVR-VNT1 effectors, activating the extreme resistance known as effector-triggered immunity (ETI; Oh et al., 2009). The ETI is characterized by a hypersensitive response (HR) and associated disease-resistance responses (Oh et al., 2014). The 2A_1 clonal lineage of P. infestans is the dominant genotype in Kenya that has completely displaced the old US-1 lineage on potato (Njoroge et al., 2016). 2A_1 is also rapidly spreading in the other east African countries and was also the only clonal lineage used for bioassays in this study. This P. infestans lineage expresses all the three corresponding AVR-BLB1, AVR-BLB2 and AVR-VNT1 effectors in the field and therefore will not be able to overcome quickly these 3R transgenic varieties (Ghislain et al., 2018).
In this study, 3 R genes was introduced as a stack made of genes from wild relatives of S. tuberosum (RB and Rpi-blb2 from S. bulbocastanum and Rpi-vnt1.1 from  S. venturii) into African farmer-preferred potato varieties ‘Tigoni’ and ‘Shangi’. Detached-leaf assay versus whole-plant leaf assay was tested to predict the level of resistance to late blight. Finally, the gene expression of each of the three R genes in transgenic events, from both varieties was analyzed.



Construction of the 3R potato gene construct
The pCIP99 gene construct is described elsewhere (Ghislain et al., 2018). Briefly, the backbone vector is the pCAMBIA2300 plant transformation binary vector (vector provided by CAMBIA Australia) in which from the left border to the right border, the nptII gene in transcription orientation was inserted toward the left border and the three R genes in transcription orientation towards the right border (Rpi-vnt1.1, RB and then Rpi-blb2). The full size of the T-DNA is 18,585 bp whereas the resulting plant transformation vector pCIP99 is 24,819 bp long (Figure 1). The vector pCIP99 was then transferred by electroporation into the Agrobacterium tumefaciens hypervirulent strain EHA105 (Hood et al., 1993).
Agrobacterium-mediated transformation of ‘Tigoni’ and ‘Shangi’ varieties
Internodal explants from 4-week-old plantlets were used for transformation using previously published protocol with minor modifications (Cuellar et al., 2006). The Agrobacterium tumefaciens EHA105 strain bearing pCIP99 was incubated for 15 h at 28°C in LB semi-solid medium containing 100 mg/L kanamycin. A single colony was taken with a scalpel and then used to cut internodal explants of potato plantlets of the ‘Tigoni’ and ‘Shangi’ varieties. The infected internodes were placed on co-culture medium and subsequently transferred to regeneration medium (Cuellar et al., 2006) containing 50 mg/L kanamycin  and  200 mg/L  carbenicilllin. To avoid false kanamycin resistant regenerants, calli were induced from leaf segments of the putative transgenic plantlets and cultured for 4 weeks on a highly selective medium (4.3 g/L salt Murashige and Skoog, 20 g/L sucrose, 20 g/L mannitol, 0.5 g/L 2-(N-Morpholino) ethanesulfonic acid, 0.5 g/L polyvinylpyrrolidone, 0.2 g/L glutamine, 0.04 g/L adenine sulfate, 1 ml/L of vitamins GAP, 1 mg/L naphthalene acetic acid, 0.1 mg/L 6-Bencyl-aminopurine, 200 mg/L kanamycin, and 2 g/L Gelrite, pH 5.6) under in vitro propagation conditions. Plantlets that did not form calli were deemed false kanamycin resistant regenerants and discarded.
Molecular characterization by PCR
Genomic DNA was extracted from putative transformed plants using a phenol-chloroform extraction method (Gawel and Jarret, 1991). To confirm the presence of the T-DNA in putative ‘Tigoni’ and ‘Shangi’ events, primers overlapping the region between RB - Rpi-blb2 and RB - Rpi-vnt1.1, and primers overlapping the left and right border regions flanking the T-DNA insert, were designed and used for PCR amplification (Table 1). Conventional PCR was done in a GeneAmp® PCR System 9700 (Applied Biosystems, USA) under the following conditions: 94ËšC for 5 min followed by 40 cycles of 94ËšC for 30 s, 55ËšC for 30 s and 72ËšC for 1 min then 72ËšC for 10 min and 10ËšC hold.
Copy number analysis by Southern blot
Genomic DNA was extracted using a modified protocol of Gawel and Jarret (1991). 40 µg of the DNA was digested using EcoRI enzyme (20,000 U/ml EcoRI-HFTM NEB#R3101S) with 14 μL CutSmart Buffer 10X (NEB #B7204S) and 80 μL nuclease-free water to a final reaction volume of 200 μL. The DNA was digested overnight at 37°C and then separated in 0.8% agarose for 4 h at 55 V/20 cm. DNA was transferred to a positively charged nylon membrane (Roche) overnight by capillary method. Non-transgenic genomic DNA restricted by EcoRI was used as negative control and a  transgenic  event  (Vic.1)  by  Ghislain  et   al.   (2018)  previously proven to be single copy was used as a positive control. A Digoxigenin (Roche) labelled probe was made according to the manufacturer’s instructions.
P. infestans isolate collection and purification
P. infestans isolates used in this study were collected from farmers’ fields in major potato growing regions in Kenya including Kiambu (Limuru and Muguga), Molo (Elburgon, Turi and Kapsita) and Meru (Timau, and Kibirichia). Single lesion leaflets from different farms were collected during the potato-growing season of June to July 2016. The leaflets were taken to the laboratory at BecA/ILRI hub in Kenya for pathogen isolation. The diseased leaflets were washed under running tap water, tapped dry on paper towels and then incubated overnight at 18ËšC in humid chambers (Petri dishes with moist paper) to induce sporulation of P. infestans. To obtain axenic cultures of the pathogen, fresh potato tubers of the susceptible variety Asante were cleaned under running tap water and disinfected in 10% bleach (commercially referred to as Jik; Reckitt Benckiser®) for ten minutes. A sterilized pocket knife was used to cut potato tuber slices of ~1 cm thickness in a laminar flow hood. Approximately 10 mm of the sporulating leaflets were cut and placed beneath the potato tuber slices in clean petri dishes. The petri dishes were sealed with Parafilm and kept at 18°C until mycelia grew through the tuber slices. Mycelia were then transferred to modified V8 agar media made as follows.  120 g of ripened tomatoes, 200 g of fresh carrots and 4 g of clean and young potato leaves were cut to small pieces and blended in 1 L distilled water. The mixture was sieved to obtain the filtrate that was measured to 200 mL in a glass measuring cylinder. The 200-mL filtrate was then mixed with 15 g of technical agar (Oxoid Agar No. 3TM LP0013), 3 g of calcium carbonate (Uni-Chem Calcium Carbonate powder) and 50 mg of β-sitosterol (Sigma). The mixture was topped up to 1 L and autoclaved at 121ËšC for 15 min. After cooling, the media was dispensed into petri dishes and P. infestans isolates were maintained in culture. The cultures were observed under a microscope  at  a  total magnification  of  40X (4X * 10X)  to confirm that the isolates were P. infestans based on morphological descriptors. This was done by observing the presence of the characteristic lemon shaped sporangium that is found in P. infestans and the aseptate tubular hyphae that are found in oomycetes. All the isolates selected for detached-leaf assay had the P. infestans characteristics.
Inoculum preparation
Inoculum was made by adding 5 mL of distilled water to the culture plates and gently scraping off mycelia using sterile blades. The mycelial fragments were then transferred to clean Falcon® tubes containing 15 mL distilled water, vortexed for about 5 min and then sieved through four layers of cheesecloth. The resulting sporangia suspension was quantified using a haemocytometer and afterwards standardized to a concentration of 20,000 sporangia/mL. The sporangia suspensions were incubated at 4ËšC for 3 to 4 h to induce the release of zoospores. Presence of viable zoospores was confirmed under the microscope before the inoculations were performed.
Detached-leaf assays
Detached-leaf assays were done using the method described by Knapova and Gisi (2002). Leaf materials of uniform size from ‘Tigoni’ and ‘Shangi’ transgenic events and non-transgenic varieties were obtained from glasshouse grown plants at 45 days after planting. These were cleaned with distilled water and placed abaxial side up in 9 cm petri dishes containing moistened paper towels. Three isolates from Kiambu, Molo and Meru labelled, isolate 1 (Latitude 1Ëš10’52.08949” S; Longitude 36Ëš38’39.49569” E Elevation 2,142 m), isolate 2 (S 00’15’22.3”, E 035’42’58.1” Elevation 2,533 m) and isolate 3 (S 00’05’11.3”, E 037’35’43.6” Elevation 1,904 m) respectively were selected for the initial detached-leaf assay (DLA). For each isolate, five Petri dishes containing a  single leaflet per potato event were used. Four leaflets per event were inoculated at the midrib with 50 µL droplet of the 20,000 sporangia/mL suspension, while the fifth leaflet was inoculated with 50 µL droplet of sterile distilled water as a check leaflet. After inoculation, each set of five Petri dishes per isolate for each event was placed in transparent plastic bags and sealed to maintain humidity. The Petri dishes were then incubated at 18ËšC for 7 days with a 12 h photoperiod and 80% relative humidity. The leaf affected area (LAA) was assessed visually on the 7th day and was defined as the necrotic plus green area covered with sporangia. The size of the affected area was measured using a Vernier digital caliper. This experiment was repeated once for events that exhibited low or no infections. The repetition was done to verify that indeed the resistant events from the first assay would hold their resistance when inoculated with different isolates. The second assay was done using isolates from Kiambu and Meru labelled isolate 4 (Latitude 1Ëš10’52.08949” S; Longitude 36Ëš38’39.49569” E Elevation 2,142 m) and 5 (S 00’05’11.3”, E 037’35’43.6” Elevation 1,904 m) respectively. The length and width of the LAA of individual leaflets was measured in millimeters and used to calculate the average percentage of the leaf affected area using the formula (π*a*b) which calculates the area of an ellipsoid. π is the mathematical constant ‘pi’, ‘a’ is the radius of the length and ‘b’ is the radius of the width. Analysis of variance (ANOVA) was performed to measure the variation in resistance of the potato events to P. infestans isolates. The resistance scale of 0 to 9 (0 being the most resistant and 9 being the most susceptible) of Yuen and Forbes, 2009, was used as follows:
Standard scale= (Severity of test plant ∕ Severity of control plant) *9
The average of the two experiments was used to determine the resistance scale values since the experiment was repeated once.
Whole-plant assays
These assays were done according to the method adapted from Sharma et al., (2013). Transgenic events were grown from first generation tuber seeds in the glasshouse with three replicates for each event and a non-transgenic control for each. At six weeks, the plants were moved to a controlled environment (CONVIRON, Argus controls) chamber prior to inoculation. The inoculum was made and quantified as previously described but consisted of mixed sporangia of five isolates from Muguga and Meru at a final concentration of 20,000 sporangia/mL. Inoculations were performed by spraying the test plants with the sporangial suspensions using a hand-held sprayer until all the leaves were wet. The plants were covered with a transparent plastic bag until 24 h after inoculation to maintain high humidity and enhance the infection process. The Conviron chamber was maintained at a relative humidity of between 80 and 100% with a 12 h photoperiod and temperatures of 18°C for 10 days. Plants were misted once daily with sterile distilled water and were monitored every day until the experiment was terminated. The severity of infection was recorded as a percentage of foliage area that was affected 10 days post inoculation (dpi). The same resistance scale used for the DLA was used to assign resistant score values in this WPA.
R gene expression
Transcript level of the Rpi-vnt1.1, RB, and Rpi-blb2 genes in the transgenic events was done from infected plants by RTqPCR. The analysis was done at two-time points (1 day before inoculation referred to ‘Day 0’ and 3 days after inoculation referred to ‘Day 3’). RNA was extracted using the RNeasy plant minikit (Qiagen) from the infected leaves which had been frozen with liquid nitrogen and stored at -80°C. Three repetitions of samples and  RNA  extractions (biological replicates) per treatment were done. The extracted RNA concentration was estimated by spectrophotometry using a NanoDrop Micro Photometer (Thermo Scientific). cDNA was synthesized using the AccuPower® CycleScript RT kit (Bioneer) following the manufacturer´s protocol. To assess the relative expression values of each of the 3R genes, qPCR reactions were set up using Luna® Universal Probe qPCR Master Mix with gene specific primer sets (Table 1) and qRT-Rpi-vnt1.1-F and qRT-Rpi-vnt1.1-R for Rpi-vnt1.1 gene (Roman et al., 2017), qRT-RB-F and qRT-RB-R for RB gene (Kramer et al., 2009), qRT-Rpi-blb2- and qRT-Rpi-blb2-R for Rpi-blb2 gene (EPA 2006). The RTqPCR was normalized to β-tubulin housekeeping gene with primer β-tubulin F and β-tubulin R (Kramer et al., 2009) (Table 1). All reactions were prepared in a total volume of 10 µl using Luna® Universal qPCR Master Mix (New England Biolabs) as follows: 5 µl of Luna® qPCR master mix, 0.5 µl of each primer (2.5 µM), 1 µL of cDNA and 3 µl of nuclease free water. The RTqPCR was done as follows; initial denaturation at 95°C for 10 min followed by 40 cycles of 95°C or 15 s and 60°C for 1 min. The melting curve was run at 95°C for 15 s, 60°C for 1 min, 95°C for 30 s and 60°C for 15 s. Data was analyzed using DataAssistTM Software (Applied Biosystems).



Agrobacterium-mediated genetic transformation
3,000 internodes from both ‘Tigoni’ and ‘Shangi’ varieties were agro-infected. 282 putative transformed shoots was regenerated for ‘Tigoni’, of which 76 were confirmed to be highly resistant to kanamycin which represents a regeneration efficiency of 9.4%. In the case of ‘Shangi’, we regenerated 328 putative transformed shoots, of which 108 were confirmed to be highly resistant to kanamycin representing a regeneration efficiency of 10.9%. PCR was performed on 76 ‘Tigoni’ and 108 ‘Shangi’ putative events. 32 ‘Tigoni’' and 31 ‘Shangi’ events were confirmed to be positive for the nptII gene which represents a transformation efficiency of 1.1% for ‘Tigoni’ and 1% for ‘Shangi’. This transformation efficiency was lower than that reported by Orbegozo et al., (2016) of approximately 6% and Roman et al., (2017) at 7.5% for the Desiree variety transformed with Rpi-blb2 and Rpi-vnt1.1 single gene construct. However, the efficiency was comparable to that reported by Ghislain et al. (2018) at 1.5% for Victoria variety transformed with the same 3R-gene construct.
Molecular characterization of transgenic plants
PCR with overlapping primers to detect all the 3 R genes resulted in 22 ‘Tigoni’ and 13 ‘Shangi’ positive events. These transgenic events were further screened for the absence of vector backbone sequences by PCR. 13 ‘Tigoni’ and 12 ‘Shangi’ events did not have vector backbone sequences. Southern blot analysis was done on these 25 transgenic events to determine the transgene copy numbers using a 35S-nptII gene specific probe. 5 ‘Tigoni’ and 5 ‘Shangi’ (40%) events had single copies of the T-DNA  while  the  rest had multiple copies (Figure 2).  
This result was comparable to the result obtained by Ghislain et al. (2018) where 50% of the events had single T-DNA copies.
Detached-leaf assay to rapidly identify the late blight resistant transgenic events
The 13 ‘Tigoni’ and 12 ‘Shangi’ transgenic events that were positive for the 3R-gene stack were evaluated for resistance to P. infestans together with their non-transgenic equivalent varieties. Three P. infestans isolates were used for the first DLA and two isolates for the second DLA all being from the dominant 2A_1 clonal lineage in Kenya as reported by Njoroge et al., (2016). ANOVA results in Table 2 show how individual transgenic events exhibited resistance to inoculation by P. infestans isolates 1, 2 and 3 in the first assay. The output of the results showed highly significant differences (P ≤ 0.05) amongst the events in the first DLA. Out of 25 events, 19 (76%) exhibited resistance ranging from  0  to  3%  of  the average leaf affected area by LB at 7 days after inoculation. This number of resistant events was comparable to what was reported by Ghislain et al. (2018) where 75% of transgenic events transformed with this 3R gene construct were highly resistant to P. infestans. The non-transgenic ‘Tigoni’ and ‘Shangi’ varieties were completely susceptible. Transgenic events that showed susceptibility with a resistance scale values of 6-9 (Tig.8, Tig.16, Tig.141, Tig.225, and Sha.6) had multiple lesions with heavy sporulation. These events with susceptibility to late blight based on the first DLA results were not included in the second DLA. Results of the first and second assay are represented in Figure 3 where a few events exhibited susceptibility to LB in the first DLA.
The average of the resistance values in the first and second assay was used to calculate resistance values of the events. Of the 25 events tested, 19 exhibited high resistance (Table 3). The remaining five events were susceptible with visible lesions and sporulation. As expected, the two  non-transgenic  controls  were  highly susceptible and high sporulation was evident.
Whole-plant assay on DLA late blight resistant transgenic events
Results of the whole-plant assay were comparable to those of the DLA. Six transgenic events (Tig.155, Tig.267, Sha.259, Sha.2, Sha.105, and Sha.248) randomly chosen from the 20 DLA-based resistant transgenic events, were tested  in  a  single  WPA  and  all  exhibited complete resistance to LB with no infection (Figure 4). The non-transgenic ‘Tigoni’ and ‘Shangi’ varieties developed lesions at 3 days post infection (dpi) and at the end of the assay (10 dpi) the plant foliage had well over 80% infection. These results were like those observed by Ghislain et al. (2018) where transgenic events were all resistant to LB in WPA. This observation extended to the field where transgenic events that exhibited resistance in WPA maintained their resistance and non-transgenic varieties got LB (Ghislain et al., 2018). The percentage of damaged area  varied  much  less  among  repetitions for the WPA than for the DLA and between replications for the non-transgenic varieties. Therefore, the WPA as a more reliable screening method for late blight resistance was considered.
R gene expression of transgenic events
Expression study of Rpi-vnt1.1, RB and Rpi-blb2 genes was done by RT-qPCR on 17 transgenic events (9 for ‘Tigoni’ and 8 for ’Shangi’) that were available for RNA extraction and had been tested as highly resistant by detached-leaf assays. β-Tubulin housekeeping gene demonstrated stability in expression and was therefore used for relative comparison to the target genes expression. Different transgenic events showed different patterns of expression at day 0 and day 3. The Rpi-vnt1.1 gene showed a lower basal expression level compared to β-tubulin at day 0 in 15 out of 18 transgenic events and was always the lowest of the 3 R genes. The RB gene showed a higher basal level of expression in 13 out of 18 transgenic events compared to β-tubulin and presented for all of them a higher expression 3 days after infection. The Rpi-blb2 gene showed a higher basal level of expression compared to β-tubulin at day 0 in all transgenic events and was overall the R gene with slightly higher expression but with the lowest induced expression than the other 2 R genes. Twelve transgenic events showed an increase in expression after inoculation for all the three R genes. Five events (Tig.266,  Sha.102,  Sha.142  and  Sha.229)  indicated  a lower R gene expression in comparison to the reference gene expression for at least one of the three R genes after inoculation. There was insignificant change in expression levels of the RB gene for two transgenic events (Tig.76 and Sha.229). Different levels of expression of the three R genes were observed in different transgenic events. In some cases, expression levels were enhanced after inoculation and in other instances expression levels were diminished in one or all the three R genes after inoculation (Figure 5). 


In this study, the ability of a 3R-gene stack containing Rpi-vnt1.1, RB, and Rpi-blb2 genes was assessed to provide extreme resistance against P. infestans in farmer-preferred potato varieties ‘Tigoni’ and ‘Shangi’. These varieties are popular in Kenya but are also grown in neighboring east African countries. The researchers decided to use the 3R-gene stack that had been shown to confer extreme resistance to P. infestans on the transgenic events from another farmer preferred variety ‘Victoria’ in Uganda as described by Ghislain et al. (2018). The resistance of 3R transgenic events of ‘Tigoni’ and ‘Shangi’ was characterized by a total absence of symptoms of LB after detached-leaf and whole-plant assays indicating a successful defense response. It was observed that the detached-leaf assay predicts very well the resistance in the whole-plant assay. In addition, the study  demonstrated  that  the resistant transgenic events display an increase in expression of at least one of the three R genes.
In the Agrobacterium-mediated genetic transformation, a transformation efficiency of 1.1% was obtained for ‘Tigoni’ and 1% for ‘Shangi’ which was lower compared to those reported previously at 3.4, 2.8, 6 and 7.5% for the variety Desiree (Ghislain et al., 2018; Ahmad et al., 2012; Orbegozo et al., 2016; Roman et al., 2017). However, this was similar to that reported for the variety ‘Victoria’ at 1.5% (Ghislain et al., 2018). This observation confirms that transformation efficiency is genotype dependent and lower for larger T-DNA (Heeres et al., 2002). A regeneration efficiency of 9.4% was obtained for ‘Tigoni’ and 10.9% for ‘Shangi’ which is within the range of those reported previously by Orbegozo et al. (2016) at 9.5% and Roman et al., (2017) at 13% for the ‘Desiree’ variety transformed with Rpi-blb2 and Rpi-vnt1.1 single gene constructs. This does not seem to indicate a significant difference in the regeneration efficiency of these two varieties.
The DLA technique was used for the first time in Kenya to evaluate resistance of potato to P. infestans infection in addition to WPA that had previously been used by Ghislain et al. (2018). It is demonstrated herein that detached-leaf bioassays can be used to quickly determine the level of LB resistance in transgenic potato events. For the first DLA, all the events that showed resistance were equally resistant to all three isolates. The resistant transgenic events were tested for the second time using 2 isolates and they similarly showed equal resistance. DLA facilitates handling of many plant genotypes  and   allows    individual    genotypes    to   be challenged with several pathogen isolates. Noteworthy, the first and second assays gave slightly different results in that, the transgenic events exhibited a higher resistance in the second assay. Eight of the transgenic events had no infection (0% of leaf affected area) in the second assay while they exhibited a low but visible % of leaf affected area in the first assay. This difference could be attributed to the decrease in pathogen aggressiveness during the lapse of time between the first and the second assay. While the first assay was performed when the isolates were freshly isolated from the field, the second assay was performed one month after the first DLA raising the possibility that the isolates had reduced aggressiveness. Aggressiveness of isolates is usually reduced when an isolate is frequently cultured in the laboratory, additionally, different isolates differ in aggressiveness, but the differences tend to be smaller in genetically similar populations (Cooke et al., 2006). A slight difference was observed between the WPA and the DLA where the events that had exhibited hypersensitive response in DLA, exhibited extreme resistance in the WPA. This could be attributed to the different physiological states of the plants. It is expected that all the transgenic events that exhibited resistance in the WPA will exhibit extreme resistance in the field since Sharma et al., (2013) and Ghislain et al. (2018) observed that transgenic events that exhibited partial resistance in the glasshouse were completely resistant in the field. This was anticipated due to a lower natural inoculum pressure in the field compared to that used for DLA or WPA at 20,000 sporangia/ml. Additionally, field conditions cannot    be   controlled   where   sub-optimal   conditions lead to a lower infection potential. It is therefore evident from this work that DLA is a reliable method to rapidly identify transgenic events that have extreme resistance to P. infestans. This reduces the amount of time and resources needed to evaluate resistance of transgenic events.
R gene expression was shown to be induced after inoculation with P. infestans, slowly decreasing over the subsequent three days (Kramer et al., 2009; Vleeshouwers et al., 2011; Orbegozo et al., 2016; Roman et al., 2017, Ghislain et al., 2018). In this study, there was significant variation in the expression levels of the three R genes before and after inoculation. Ghislain et al. (2018) reported that there were insignificant differences of gene expression at different time points for the unique highly resistant transgenic event studied. Here, R gene expression was assayed on 17 highly resistant transgenic events. Results showed enhanced expression after inoculation in two third of the transgenic events while it reduces slightly in others. This observation appears to be consistent with that observed by Millet et al., (2009) in nwhich RB gene transcript abundance varied in different transgenic lines which was attributed to the location in which the R gene was introduced.
Five transgenic events that expressed a lower expression than that of the reference gene for at least one of their R genes still exhibited late blight resistance after inoculation. Millet et al., (2009, 2015) showed that disease resistance was affected by plant age and cultivar; even though R gene expression varied in young plants, they exhibited higher resistance in comparison to older plants and vice versa. In future analysis, screening of the transgenic events at more than two time points could provide more information on expression of the three R genes. Additionally, it would be important to do more experiments on R gene expression at different physiological stages of transgenic events. The pathogen induction of R gene expression behavior has been observed in many other plant species where expression of R genes has been enhanced after pathogen challenge (Kramer et al., 2009; Alice and Joy, 2016). However, due to the differences observed in the expression of the R genes before and after inoculation, the results do not support that an induction or high level of expression are necessary to obtain highly resistant transgenic events when using a 3R-gene stack.
In conclusion, it was demonstrated here that the three R genes (Rpi-vnt1.1, RB and Rpi-blb2) from the wild species S. bulbocastanum and S. venturii can confer extreme, possibly stable and durable, resistance to LB in the potato varieties ‘Tigoni’ and ‘Shangi’ cultivated in east Africa. Out of 13 ‘Tigoni’ and 12 ‘Shangi’ transgenic events, at least 9 transgenic events from each variety that are highly resistant were identified. These events have single T-DNA copy insertions and do not have vector backbone sequence inserted which is also desirable for releasing these transgenic events as varieties. Field evaluations under natural infection by P. infestans are needed to confirm the extreme resistance to the local Pi population since host-pathogen interactions is always influenced by environmental factors. These extremely late blight resistant transgenic events have the potential to be eventually commercialized for food security and be used in breeding programs to develop other late blight resistance varieties. However, it is yet to be demonstrated that at least one of them has conserved the integrity of all three R genes and has not interrupted an allele of an essential gene of the potato. A LB resistant variety will be important  to  smallholder  farmers because farmers will realize increased yields and save on the costs of fungicides while reducing exposure of fungicides, thereby generating more revenue and improving their livelihoods. Genetic control of late blight in potatoes not only provides a strategy to improve food security but also boost economic development in Sub-Saharan Africa where agriculture employs more than half of the total manpower and provides a livelihood for numerous small-scale producers (IMF, 2012). However, social acceptance of biotech or genetically engineered crops in Africa will need to improve, especially in countries where transgenic crops have not yet been introduced and where the regulatory environment is still under development (Chambers et al., 2014).


The authors have not declared any conflict of interests.



This research was undertaken as part of the CGIAR Research Program on Roots, Tubers and Bananas (RTB). Funding support for this work was provided by the United States Agency for International Development (USAID), the 2Blades foundation, and the Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA who funded the field sampling and isolation of P. infestans).


Ahmad ZM, Hussain I, Muhammad A, Ali S, Ali MG, Roomi S, Zia AM, Ijaz A (2012). Factor affecting Agrobacterium-mediated transformation of rice chitinase gene in Solanum tuberosum L. African Journal of Biotechnology 11(41):9716-9723.


Alice MQ, Joy B (2016). Modulation of R-gene expression across environments. Journal of Experimental Botany 67(7): 2093-2105


Chambers JA, Zambrano P, Falck-Zepeda JB, Gruère GP, Sengupta D, Hokanson K (2014). GM agricultural technologies for Africa: a state of affairs. International Food Policy Research Institute.


Cooke D, Lees A, Shaw D, Ruairidh B, Cooke L (2006). Variation in aggressiveness in Phytophthora infestans . British potato council. 


Cuellar W, Gaudin A, Solórzano D, Casas A, Ñopo L, Chudalayandi P, Medrano G, Kreuze J, Ghislain M (2006). Self-excision of the antibiotic resistance gene nptII using a heat inducible Cre-loxP system from transgenic potato. Plant molecular biology 62(1-2):71-82.


Devaux A, Kromann P, Ortiz O (2014). Potatoes for sustainable global food security. Potato Research 57(3-4):185-199.


EPA Ireland (2006). Response from BASF to request further information, publicly.


Gawel NJ, Jarret RI (1991). A modified CTAB DNA extraction procedure for Musa and Ipomoea. Plant Molecular Biology Reporter 9(3):262-266.


Ghislain M, Arinaitwe AB, Magembe E, Njoroge A, Rivera C, Román ML, Tovar JC, Gamboa S, Forbes GA, Kreuze JF, Barekye A, Kiggundu A (2018). Stacking three late blight resistance genes from wild species directly into African highland potato varieties confers complete field resistance to local blight races. Plant Biotechnology Journal 17(6):1119-1129.


Haesaert G, Vossen HJ, Custers R, Loose M, Haverkort A, Heremans B, Hutten R, Kessel G, Landschoot S, Droogenbroeck B, Visser R, Gheysen G (2015). Transformation of the potato variety Desiree with single or multiple resistance genes increases resistance to late blight under field conditions. Crop protection 77:163-175.


Hannukkala AO, Kaukoranta T, Lehtinen A, Rahkonen A (2007). Late blight epidemics on potato in Finland 1933-2002; increased and earlier occurrence of epidemics associated with climate change and lack of rotation. Plant Pathology 56(1):167-176.


Haverkort A, Struik P (2015). Yield levels of potato crops: recent achievements and future prospects. Field Crops Research 182:76-85.


Haverkort AJ, Struik PC, Visser RGF, Jacobsen E (2009). Applied Biotechnology to Combat Late Blight in Potato Caused by Phytophthora Infestans. Potato Research 52(3):249-264.


Heeres P, Schippers-Rozenboom M, Jacobsen E, Visser RG (2002). Transformation of a large number of potato varieties: genotype-dependent variation in efficiency and somaclonal variability. Euphytica 124(1):13-22.


Hood EE, Gelvin SB, Melchers LS, Hoekema A (1993). New Agrobacterium helper plasmids for gene transfer to plants (EHA105). Transgenic Research 2(4):208-218.


International Monetary Fund (IMF) (2012). International Jobs Report, Economist Intelligence Unit, Washington, DC.


International Year of the Potato (IYP) (2008). The Potato United Nations Food and Agricultural Organization Retrieved 6 August 2015.


Kaguongo W, Nyangweso A, Mutunga J, Nderitu J (2013). A policymakers' Guide to Crop Diversification: The Case of the Potato in Kenya, FAO, Rome. 



Knapova G, Gisi U (2002). Phenotypic and genotypic structure of Phytophthora infestans populations on potato and tomato in France and Switzerland. Plant Pathology 51(5):641-653.


Kramer LC, Choudoir MJ, Wielgus SM, Bhaskar PB, Jiang J (2009). Correlation between transcript abundance of the RB gene and the level of the RB-mediated late blight resistance in potato.  Molecular Plant-Microbe Interactions 22(4):447-455.


Laititi M (2014). Potato market survey in Kenya: An agricultural product value chain approach. International Journal of Business and Management Review 2(6):59-87.


Millet BP, Mollov DS, Lorrizo M, Carputo D, Bradeen JM (2009). Changes in disease resistance phenotypes associated with plant physiological age are not caused by variation in R gene transcript abundance. Molecular Plant-Microbe Interactions 22(3):362-368.


Millet BP, Gao L, Lorrizo M, Carputo D, Bradeen JM (2015). Potato tuber blight resistance phenotypes correlate with RB transgene transcript levels in an age-dependent manner. Phytopathology 105(8):1131-1136.


Muthoni J, Shimelis H, Melis R (2013). Potato production in Kenya: Farming systems and production constraints. Journal of Agricultural Science 5(5):182-197.


National Potato Council of Kenya (NPCK) (2015). Potato Variety Catalogue Retrieved from the National Potato Council of Kenya Website. 



New Partnership for Africa's Development (NEPAD) (2013). Agriculture in Africa: Transformation and Outlook: Prepared by Roger Blein, Martin Bwalya, Sloans Chimatiro, Benoît Faivre-Dupaigre, Simon Kisira, Henri Leturque and Augustin Wambo-Yamdjeu 15 p.


Njoroge A, Tusiime G, Forbes G, Yuen J (2016). Displacement of US‐1 clonal lineage by a new lineage of Phytophthora infestans on potato in Kenya and Uganda. Plant Pathology 65(4):587-592.


Oh S-K, Kim H, Choi D (2014). Rpi-blb2-mediated late blight resistance in Nicotiana benthamiana requires SGT1 and salicylic acid-mediated signaling but not RAR1 or HSP90. FEBS Letters 588(7):1109-1115.


Oh S-K, Young C, Lee M, Oliva R, Bozkurt TO, Cano LM, Win J, Bos JI, Liu HY, van Damme M, Morgan W, Choi D, van der Vossen EA, Vleeshouwers VG, Kamoun S (2009). In planta expression screens of Phytophthora infestans RXLR effectors reveal diverse phenotypes, including activation of the Solanum bulbocastanum disease resistance protein Rpi-blb2. The Plant Cell 21:2928-2947.


Orbegozo J, Roman ML, Rivera C, Gamboa S, Tovar JC, Forbes GA, Lindqvist-Kreuze H, Kreuze JF, Ghislain M (2016). Rpi-blb2 gene from Solanum bulbocastanum confers extreme resistance to late blight disease in potato. Plant Cell, Tissue and Organ Culture 125(2):69-281.


Roman ML, Izarra M, Lindqvist-Kreuze H, Rivera C, Gamboa S, Tovar JC, Kreuze JF, Forbes GA, Ghislain M (2017). R/Avr gene expression study of Rpi-vnt1.1 transgenic potato resistant to the Phytophthora infestans clonal lineage EC-1. Plant Cell, Tissue and Organ Culture 131(2):259-268.


Schumann GL, D'Arcy CJ (2005). Late blight of potato and tomato. The Plant Health Instructor 724-733.


Sharma BP, Forbes AG, Manandhar KH, Shrestha SM, Thapa RB (2013). Determination of Resistance to Phytophthora infestans on Potato Plants in Field, Laboratory and Greenhouse Conditions. Journal of Agricultural Science 5(5):9752-9760 ISSN 1916-9752E-ISSN 1916-9760.


Ssengooba T, Hakiza JJ (1999). The current status of late blight caused by Phytophthora infestans in Africa, with emphasis on eastern and southern Africa. Proceedings of Global Initiative on Late Blight Conference, March 16-19 Quito, Ecuador pp. 25-28.


Vleeshouwers VGA, Dooijeweert W, Govers F, Kamoun S, Colon TL (2000). The hypersensitive response is associated with host and non-host resistance to Phytophthora infestans. Planta 210(6):853-864.


Vleeshouwers VG, Raffaele S, Vossen JH, Champouret N, Oliva R, Segretin ME, Pel MA (2011). Understanding and exploiting late blight resistance in the age of effectors. Annual Review of Phytopathology 49:507-531.


Wurster R (1977). Social science research and training: report of the planning conference on social science research and training held at CIP-Lima, Peru, August 8-12, 1977. Lima: Centro Internacional de la papa.


Yuen JE, Forbes GA (2009). Estimating the level of susceptibility to Phytophthora infestans in potato genotypes. Phytopatholog 99(6):782-786.


Zhu S, Li Y, Vossen JH, Visser GRF, Jacobsen E (2012). Functional stacking of three resistance genes against Phytophthora infestans in potato. Transgenic Research 21(1):89-99.